FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  Sport stadiums in SA - how do they compare

Sport stadiums in SA - how do they compare

Started by clevermike6 REPLIES85 VIEWS· 04 Oct 2014, 11:33
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
04 Oct 2014, 11:33
#1
04 Oct 2014, 11:33#1

Lets look at the various Sanzar countries and the main stadia available comapring them and start with SA:-


Cape Town  -   Newlands,  Green Point Stadium

Port Elizabeth -  Nelson Mandela Stadium

Durban - Moses Madibha Stadium, Kingspark Stadium

Bloemfontein -  Springbok Park Stadium

Johanesburg -  Ellis Park, Soccer City,  Soweto Stadium

Pretoria -  Loftus Versfeld

Nelspruit -  Mbombela Stadium


Of the above there are five tradional stadiums - Newlands, Ellis Park, Loftus Versfeld,  Kings Park and Springbok Park.   Loftus versveld and Springbok Park has been upgarded drastically with a view ot the 2010 Soccer World Cup.     All the other stadiums were built specifically for the Soccer World Cup.  


Basically7 the available stadia is much bigger seating wise and much more modern than most of the stadiums in New Zealand and Australia.   New Zealand has the roof-covered stadium in Dunedin - while Austraiahas the Olymic Stadia in Melbourne and Sydney - which seating wise is slightly bigger than the SA stadiums.   


Howevr, in essense from a staium perspective the SA stadia is of better quality than the NZ and Australia stadia.   


The problem is that three of the Stadia mentioned (Kingspark, Newlands and Ellis Park) have been at the heart of SA Rugby for decades and they may fall away in the next decade.  I cannot forsee that any of the three will be upgraded - and there is th danger that they do not comply with legislative requirements anymore.   All stadia in SA has been given notice that they must upgrade the stadia to ensure public safety - but the norms has been set very high and it will cost a fortune to upgrade those to meet requirements.   They have been given 2 years notice - exppiring in 2016 -  to upgrade the stadiums or their licences would be withdrawn to operate rugby or other sporting activities.   I cannot see how the rugby franchises would spend billions on stadia upgrading, since the cities are well-served with other modern  stadia, chances are that thy will be closed down by 2016.              

JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
04 Oct 2014, 13:35
#2
04 Oct 2014, 13:35#2
It's a shame to see the old stadiums be pulled down or not used for top level rugby but it happens. 
Athletic Park (Wellington NZ) had such a rich history for NZ rugby but in truth it was a little rough, old world for sure. Concrete urinals so the smell of 1000s of fans peeing in them for generations was all part of the "ambience" lol 
Now we have the Cake tin. More modern for sure and some protection from the howling southerly wind. The Cake tin is different, necessary but not the same. We all move on as the stadiums age and the number of fans grows 
AG
AgPleezDeddyClub Pro900 posts
04 Oct 2014, 14:29
#3
04 Oct 2014, 14:29#3
 It'll be a sad day when we don't go to Kings Park, Newlands and Ellis Park anymore but like JW said sometimes it's for the good of the games, fans and rugby itself. 
BL
BlikkiesPro1,526 posts
04 Oct 2014, 15:04
#4
04 Oct 2014, 15:04#4

A major problem with many of the new 2010 Soccer World Cup stadiums is that the requirements of rugby were not incorporated in their design. Many (if not all) of them were built with the in goal area far too small thus creating a safety hazard to the players.


The playing field on many if them are also covered with a grass type required by soccer that are far too dainty for rugby because they can not withstand rough handling like scrums, mauls and line-outs.   

AG
AgPleezDeddyClub Pro900 posts
04 Oct 2014, 15:21
#5
04 Oct 2014, 15:21#5
 I also think that newer stadiums, don't hold atmosphere so well. Some examples in football would the New Wembley, where everything feels a bit flat. 
GE
generaltitPro3,164 posts
04 Oct 2014, 17:34
#6
04 Oct 2014, 17:34#6
Well just 1 and a 1/2 hours to go.Quite nerve racking.

Newlands takes all other fields to the cleaners...it's beautiful, in a pleasant suburb...near one of my schools when I was a junior...was a very pretty suburb then...oak trees and gardens and a trout stream that Ohlsons Breweries used the pure mountain water to supplement their breweries...that's all gone but Ellis Park and Kings Park were in slum areas, dirty and industrial.

Yes Newlands to rugby (and cricket ground) is like Lords in England to cricket. To move rugby to Greenpoint ( a cemented slum...soccer area) is sacriledge...I hope it will never happen...surely not, it's the same in England of destroying Lords...let some fineness and taste remain.
GE
generaltitPro3,164 posts
04 Oct 2014, 18:15
#7
04 Oct 2014, 18:15#7
Well just 1 and a 1/2 hours to go.Quite nerve racking.

Newlands takes all other fields to the cleaners...it's beautiful, in a pleasant suburb...near one of my schools when I was a junior...was a very pretty suburb then...oak trees and gardens and a trout stream that Ohlsons Breweries used the pure mountain water to supplement their breweries...that's all gone but Ellis Park and Kings Park were in slum areas, dirty and industrial.

Yes Newlands to rugby (and cricket ground) is like Lords in England to cricket. To move rugby to Greenpoint ( a cemented slum...soccer area) is sacriledge...I hope it will never happen...surely not, it's the same in England of destroying Lords...let some fineness and taste remain.
— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news