FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  The Irony

The Irony

Started by 3ku16 REPLIES97 VIEWS· 05 Oct 2014, 03:08
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
3K
3ku1Pro2,580 posts
05 Oct 2014, 03:08
#1
05 Oct 2014, 03:08#1

Its funny after hearing for a while about NZ wins being heavily ref assisted. SA get one with an assist from the ref. And its almost a ghost town on that front  The last twenty NZ were clearly dominating, once again their supeior fitness lvls were clear . It was also clear that SA were fading. Just a bit of bad luck. In an other wise perfect defense SA were staring down another defeat. Initially their was nothing wrong with the Messam arm. It was a very physical game, Burger looked like he was going full in. But then last moment he slipped, and so did Messam. Not worth a penalty, and it wouldent of been if the crowd diddnt hv a mentle, and it wasent slowed down to mame it worser then it actually was. Crowd clearly put pressure on Barnes, and Lambie kicked a brilliant penalty. But im not gonna sit here and do a Benno  and cry foul. Theirs an oppurtunity here for NZ fans to set a precedence. It was a very controversial decision that snatched victory from NZ. I just hate it when refs determine the outcomes of games. And effectively ruined the contest for both teams. But credit to SA, the first half was the best ive seen SA play in years. It really set them up for the win. NZ missing alot of players, really made a great comeback and should of wan if it wasent for some clumsiness from Messam, and Peterson on Kerr Barlow (NZ even had to finish the game with Slade at Halfback lol). So i dont think nz well be too dissappointed, SA well be happy they finnally got the W over NZ, albeit not on their terms. Clearly the two best sides in the world. Oh and Fyi please pretty please keep Matfeild in the Starting line up, the guy has no physicality and clearly could not handle the physicality and feriouscness of the All Blacks and test rugby. 

sharkbok
sharkbokCaptain23,294 posts
05 Oct 2014, 04:59
#2
05 Oct 2014, 04:59#2
 3ku1
 
Status: Bok regular 
Posts: 1123The Irony
October 05, 2014, 03:08:57

 Initially their was nothing wrong with the Messam arm. Burger looked like he was going full in. But then last moment he slipped, and so did Messam. Not worth a penalty, 

So an fore arm elbow to the head is not worth a penalty......
The ref watched it on the big screen in slow motion and standard speed. Their was another post winging created by a Kiwi about the referee. Another Kiwi doing a Beeno.....Another winging Kiwi blaming the ref......."I just hate it when refs determine the outcomes of games."NZ missing alot of players, really made a great comeback and should of wan.


MO
MozartCaptain49,914 posts
05 Oct 2014, 06:24
#3
05 Oct 2014, 06:24#3
Have to agree SB. It looked like a pretty clear cut high shoulder charge. Barnes' statement that it was accidental was hardly credible given the way he held his arm. My first reaction was yellow.
JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
05 Oct 2014, 07:10
#4
05 Oct 2014, 07:10#4
 Well they say imitation is the sincerest but I never did like that expression, lol
Boks played the style of play the AB have adopted & it was a crowd pleaser. No dominance in the scrum or in the physicality but some sweet back play & very effective play at the breakdown.
ABs will know what their mistakes were & will correct them & improve. Boks have room to improve in their selections. Both teams have more depth now as new-ish players were brought in & gained experience.
Full credit to Vermeulen for playing like he didn't even have a rib injury & we all know that is not easy.
On Messam mess up, you  may notice that Burger had his head on the ball so in trying to dislodge the ball it may have given some the impression the shot was intended for the head. Both players slipped.  A penalty was given, the game was won end of story. 
MO
moolaaPro2,380 posts
05 Oct 2014, 07:14
#5
05 Oct 2014, 07:14#5
 Definitely a penalty but no hint of a no-arms tackle from either the TMO or the ref. The TMO was hinting that he thought Vermeulen had slipped into it and therefore not even a penalty.Anyway, full marks to the Boks. they were due a win and the luck went their way for a change. Pollard was outstanding in the first half and man of the match for me. Vermeulen was quiet in the first half but played like he has been recently in the 2nd and got better as the game went on. He seemed to have the stamina when the rest of the Bok forwards were fading badly in the last 20 and looking like folding. As for as the other Bok backs, JDV still runs up out of the line too much and I thought Serfontein was found wanting in defence as was Hendricks but at least Hendricks had Savea as an excuse! No problem with Barnes' reffing. Very few controversial decisions so good all round.As for the ABs, I'm proud of the way they came back in the 2nd half considering they had no Retallick, lost Moody, Thrush and Conrad to concussion and TKB after only a few minutes on the paddock. Hell, we had to play Slade at halfback for the last crucial minutes when the Boks were out on their feet and ripe for the picking!Bring on the Wobblies for us, the EOYT and 2015 season!!
BE
Beeno1Captain40,032 posts
05 Oct 2014, 07:28
#6
05 Oct 2014, 07:28#6
Boks dominated the last 10 minutes so what is this bit about fading at the end . Abs had the better of the first 30 minutes of second half. When abs got ahead Boks came to life.
It would be nice if the kbbs could stop squealing. A yellow should have been given. Barnes was very lenient on the wee abs.
Frankly the Boks should have been undefeated this RC.  The only decent thing for the wee abs to do is hand the RC cup to its rightful owners - the Mighty Boks. Another travesty - one of so many.


JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
05 Oct 2014, 07:35
#7
05 Oct 2014, 07:35#7

Planet rugby - a reality check for wee Beeno

Just_win
 
Status: Rugby Legend 
Posts: 6319RE: Sensational Springboks topple champs; Planet Rugby
October 04, 2014, 23:01:56 Beeno: the Boks won but don't delude yourself it wasn't close or that the Boks were dominant in the last 10 minutes. Read this article, notice the following text:

"The Boks were running out of gas though and when Conrad Smith split De Villiers and Serfontein to put Ben Smith over in the corner, the words Déjà vu were whispered around the stadium.

Barrett held his nerve to slot the conversion from the touchline to set up a grandstand finish with the scores at 24-20 and twelve minutes on the clock.

Three minutes latter, with the Springboks looking dead on their feet, Coles crossed in the corner to give the world champions a one-point lead."

— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news