FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  The worst Bok loosie choices in ages

The worst Bok loosie choices in ages

Started by Mozart2 REPLIES229 VIEWS· 17 May 2012, 17:06
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
MO
MozartCaptain49,914 posts
17 May 2012, 17:06
#1
17 May 2012, 17:06#1

Our problem is usually who to leave out....now we are scraping to find 3 test calibre loosies.

 

We start with a choice between Spies and Daniels at 8th man. Spies a player who goes anonymously through whole seasons these days.....and Daniels a fighter, who may not be quite physical enough in static close tests. I'd still take the guy who tries, Keegan Daniels. Hell I might even try Ashley Johnson again....as he showed in his long range try a few weeks back, he still has the pace and is a strong chappie, with a combatative streak. What a pity Alberts has declined so dramatically.

 

At open side we have Brussouw and nobody else. But it was discouraging to see Pocock tackle Heindrich and easily strip him a few weeks back. One can't help but feel when these two meet again, unless the Bok tight forwards totally dominate, Pocock will have his number, just as in the RWCQF.

 

Openside, which seemed a treasure trove of riches when the season started.....now comes down to Marcel Coetzee and the hirsute Josh Strauss. Neither is ideal. Strauss is a plodding runner who loses the ball far too often....and his defence is porous. Marcel is a very smart young player, but needs more exposure. At a pinch I would go for the talent. Stander may be another option, who looks more physically mature at this stage, but I havent seen enough of his play. Elstadt I fear will be exposed as just too ponderous in tests.....but maybe not by the Poms. So that could be a safe choice

 

With all that, the loosie area, as Rugby 365 opines, could be our weak link against England. Who would have thunk it!

BE
Beeno1Captain40,032 posts
17 May 2012, 17:32
#2
17 May 2012, 17:32#2

Yup its crazy to be in this position . But there I little doubt who Meyer will pick so lets hope they do the job.

Ashley Johnston has played very well. Can he still do it at test level?

Elstadt will become a great number 7 in the Gert Smal mould?

Lots of uncertainties right now re loose forwards. I do think however that our tight five should be better and that will helpany loose trio picked.

SA
Saffolk Captain30,741 posts
17 May 2012, 17:37
#3
17 May 2012, 17:37#3

So far from reality its scary......your take on our lossies as with most players is just nonsense. Brussouw was by far better than Pocock in that contest between them. I hardly noticed Pocock that day. Daniel is not even in contention as a 8 and can only be considered as a 6.

We have loosies to burn and it is a case of who to leave out more than ever before.

At 6, the options are Brussouw, Daniel and Kolisi - all 3 better than most countries first choices

At 7, the options are Elstadt, Coetzee, J.Potgieter, CJ Stander, J.Strauss, Vermeulen, Schalk, Alberts, v/d Walt, Arno Botha, Deysel- again all better than most sides first choices

At 8, the options are Spies, Vermeulen, J.Strauss, CJ Stander and Kankan

We have so much depth at loosie its scarey

 

— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news