JWJust_win
Captain18,570 posts
JWJust_winCaptain18,570 posts
06 Sept 2014, 22:26#2
Good call by the citing Commissioner.
Tomas appeared to use his head. You will note we are not complaining that he should have been given a red card during the game & by not giving him one it impacted the game.
GTGonzo the Great
Club Pro560 posts
GTGonzo the GreatClub Pro560 posts
06 Sept 2014, 22:34#3
well of course not because it didnt. different kettle of fish bra.
07 Sept 2014, 01:22#4
Good job. Thuggish Bakkies like hit.
JWJust_win
Captain18,570 posts
JWJust_winCaptain18,570 posts
07 Sept 2014, 01:25#5
He's probably mad because we kicked him off this site Just joking, lol
07 Sept 2014, 05:52#6
Its the usual garbage like Greyling [ which as Seb knows is a wee little trout fishy ] trying to make a name for themselves by attacking a living legend like our Rutchie !But like many a young buck in a western moovieyah when the dust settles Rutchie stands blowing smoke from his guns while the challenger lays in the dust .......
FOForeverArizona
Club Pro580 posts
FOForeverArizonaClub Pro580 posts
07 Sept 2014, 07:05#7
Warfalt this isn't the 1920s....
07 Sept 2014, 07:58#8
What ? did someone just tell you that or did you work out how to use a calender ?Google ? Isnt technology great ? It can even help the terminally stupid like you.
BEBeeno1
Captain40,032 posts
BEBeeno1Captain40,032 posts
07 Sept 2014, 09:56#9
Wee mcaaaw gets less than what he deserves. Greyling merely lent on the poppet! All this angst about nothing. mcaaaws groupies need to harden up and stop squealing when wee mcaaaw gets roughed up a tad for his indescr etions!
07 Sept 2014, 11:12#10
So your advocating filthy play are you ? Or is it only against KIwis ? Typical idiot behaviour .And Ritchie was on his own side of the ruck stupid so how is that his indiscretion ?moronic post of yours yet again .
CLclevermike
Coach57,555 posts
CLclevermikeCoach57,555 posts
07 Sept 2014, 12:08#11
Wardad
It seems the referees do not like it when messrs McCaw and Carter gets their comeuppence. The por dears just ghave to keel over and the outcome is soo sympethatic. If not the referees than the coiting commissioner.
JWJust_win
Captain18,570 posts
JWJust_winCaptain18,570 posts
07 Sept 2014, 12:35#12
Man, you SA posters are so blind to foul play when it comes to Richie.
No rugby fan should condone blatant foul play. The hit on Carter was fair play, the hit on McCaw was not (according to the Judiciary). No comment from you guys about the fact that Tomas should have been red carded during the game of course. I guess that was not a "bent ref" situation, lol
07 Sept 2014, 14:12#13
So was Savea cited for no arms tackle late and high?? of course not...
JWJust_win
Captain18,570 posts
JWJust_winCaptain18,570 posts
07 Sept 2014, 14:24#14
No one was condoning high tackles.
07 Sept 2014, 14:46#15
Not-so-clever Mike ,if you condone blatant thuggery because of some perceived infringements by Maccaw then shame on you .Do you not know the difference between foul play and rule infractions ? As I have said before if Ritchie was a Bok y'all be singin a different tune .I even got a rabid loud mouthed wallaby fan at Suncorp to admit this .Shameful and part of the reason people think of foul play when the boks are mentioned ,after all if some of their fans condone it it must be true eh ?Notice no Kiwis here condone it ? Not even when its one of ours ? Man up like your teams and captain and coach who arent impressed by thuggery [ ever wonder why Greyling dssapeared so quickly ? ] Its stupid and obnoxious and has lowered you in not ony my eyes Mike.
08 Sept 2014, 14:46#16
I see Ole Cruz gets a week off......Will get plenty of time to pen another diatribe to a few "believers"on this site no doubt!
08 Sept 2014, 15:18#17
Ward, I gotto agree with you here. No Thuggery should be accepted from anyone. Some folks here are very blind when it comes to the Boks vs whoever. I didn't see the incident between Lavanini and McCaw, so I can't comment on it, but foul play is foul play. No matter who commits it and a gainst who.
08 Sept 2014, 16:08#18
Too true Blue Bok ,I have always disliked Hore and anyone like him I dont care who they play for ,same goes for that arshole Loe attacking poor Paul Carrozas nose .If either had been banned for life then good riddance .
BEBeeno1
Captain40,032 posts
BEBeeno1Captain40,032 posts
08 Sept 2014, 16:42#19
Hey ou maaaikie my condolences on this very sad and tough moment for you. You dear man have been lowered in warped DUD eyes. Man thats a fate worse than death! The end of all self esteem!!!!
All I can say is congrats! Bwhahahahahahahahahaha
Nobody likes really dirty play but oaks like wee mcaaaw shouldn't provoke. He is being held together with strapping and one hard tackle from an angry Vermuelen could be the end! Now nobody wants to see the end of Ritchie do we.
08 Sept 2014, 16:47#20
Ritchie justs dusts off the wee fly-speck hits and continues to have a fabulous winning career unlike Taquiri ,Cooper,greyling and the froggy eye gougerie and Tomas the not-so tank-like wee engine that couldnt [ and shouldnt] and so on ....

sharkbok
Captain23,294 posts

sharkbokCaptain23,294 posts
08 Sept 2014, 18:44#21
Cheating is cheating. While violent play should not be condoned, neither should the cheating play of Mccaw either. Even the other New Zealand SuperXV teams complain about his approach to the game, and he does get tramped on by them as well.
Their is a difference between an open sider flank like George Smith pushing the laws to slow the ball down or compete in the 50/50 situations, than flat out cheating.
Mccaw when he played about 2 years ago against the Boks was the most unsporting play I have seen in rugby. He is lying on the ground at a ruck on the other side. The South African scrum half looks to see where his flyhalf is, the referee also glances up to check the backline offline status. Mccaw watches the referee look away, places his arm in the ruck onto the Bok side, and pulls the ball onto the New Zealand side. Just as the referee turns around, Mccaw puts his face down and pretends that he is doing nothing. The referee then assumes that the Bok scrumhalf has knocked the ball on and awards a scrum to the All Blacks. This is unsporting conduct. Anyone who condones this type of play condones cheating. While taking the law into your own hands is not the way too go, it happens with Mccaw because players are getting frustrated with his cheating. He has taken professional cheating beyond a level that is sporting conduct. He should be penalized more frequenly, even if it is after a match where their is video evidence.