Which Players Should the boks back for the end of year tour?

Okay, 

So we have 3 matches left. The boys have 2 weeks off before being paraded around France for some World Cup promo nonsense. 

But it means they'll have another five weeks to go. Some of the coaches moaned that the bubble made life hard, but most of the players are Europe based now so it shouldn't be a big factor. 

We also have our URC rugby teams out there at the moment. 

BUT, not sure I would pick any of that bunch. 

So for me

Drop

Orie, Mostert, Willie, Elstadt,  Willemse, Wiese 

In

RG, Coetzee, Leyds, Serfontein, Esterhuizen,  Goosen

The other question  is whether we should give our fringe players a decent run and try to create comptition in the team. 

Pollard and Faf has been really questionable. If anything, they are in the UK and France and always be brought back in again. 

Starting 15 against Wales and Scotland

15. Fassi / Steyn

14. Nkosi

13. Kriel

12. Esterhuizen

11. Kolbe

10. Jantjies / Goosen

9. Reinach  /  Jantjies

8. Dan Du Preez

7. Jean Luke

6. Van Staden  / Marcel Coetzee

5. Lood

4. RG

3. Wilcow Louw / Koch

2. Marx

1. Kitshoff / Du Toit

However,  probably not enough as we need more dark skin brothers. So probably see the likes of

OX, Scarra, Rasta, Trevor, Kolisi, Noche, Pepse, Simanale making a return and not to forget Orie

Good lock combo, I see you are still pusing  for Richardson as well as Evan Roos.

Would like to see Dweba have a few more cracks at it. 

Nohamba is still playing off the bench and the sharks have brought in Pienaar. So not sure if he is  match fit. 

What happened to Jaden Hendrikse, is it out for the rest of the year?

Let "Willie Manilli" take it as it comes... and keep on running

He cannot blame it on the rain

He gave it his all or nothing

I'm gonna miss you Willie 

The 80's kids will get it

1. Fassi doesn't belong at test level. 
2. Wiese has been one of the very few good Boks this season, his unmatched ability within the squad to get over the gainline will be important up north. We simply do not possess another forward who can do it like he can. 
3. Willie is the best 15 we have. Once again, he is taking the flack for our inept coaches. We won't field anyone better. Frans had some good kicks, but if you want to actually ignite our tier 3 attack, we cannot be without Willie. 
4. Nkosi has been weak. Poor defence, poor aerial skills and a lack of work ethic. 
5. Reinach has been the best 9 on display. Faf just isn't rounded enough. I was watching some of the 2018 tests, and Faf looked a lot fitter. In fact, the team looked much fitter in general.
6. Limp. A big man, but so underpowered. A nothing carrier, poor hands, very immobile and slow off the mark. Looks cumbersome. We look unfit, and Limp's unathletic state still stands out. 
7. van Rensburg is immensely powerful. He is the most impressive lock in terms of power since Flip and Bakkies. He was cleaning the Pumas off the ball like they were toys. Very mobile and with nice skills. He looked very impressive. 
8. Damian. He isn't just poor, he is getting worse. Sadly, all he has to do is walk over the line unopposed and the media is crowing his greatness. Damian is the clog in the team. What PTSD is to our pack is what Dumbian is to the midfield and backline. Over 50 caps of nothing. Absolutely outclassed and outgunned in every test. 
9. Marx is very clearly the best hooker in world rugby. Mbonambi is very good, among the very best, but Marx is better and is now becoming critical to the team. 
10. Esterhuizen has been treated badly by this uncoaching duo. We need him, and desperately. Unlike Dumbian, he actually has a good connection with Am. The best passing of all of our backs and with RG as the biggest offload threat. 
11. RG is the best lock in the country. He is a complete lock. We need his dynamism, but also his combative nature. He is a very dominant player with a hardy mentality. 
12. Kwagga needs to start at 6, with Dan at 7. This is now a must. Kolisi is not test quality. He has tried hard, but he simply cannot elevate his play to where it needs to be. His leadership doesn't exist. 
13. The PTSD myth must end now. The reasons have been stated enough at this point. We don't need him. 

Some of the interesting selections amongst others include JD Schickerling, Elrigh Louw and Evan Roos. I'd also like to see a new and younger alternative to Pollard and the permanent replacement of Willie Le Roux and sooner rather than later the athletic Ruhan Nel has to be given an extended run.

Yep, I missed that, there is no future for Nel based on age. I've yet to see Hendrikse, have seen Fassi who has natural speed and might add another dimension to the back three and I hope he has a bigger boot than the pap boot of Le Roux, everytime Le Roux kicked I cringed.

Well,  I have not seen enough of the two Hendrikse brothers.  See both is still very young 21 and 20. Both are tall and seems to be quick. But they are too young to start dropping into the bok team and need a few seasons under their belt. 

But I also see the other Hendrikse broke his ankle too. 

But I agree, we need to get some cover at 10.  Bosch hasn't really been performing and has gone back into his shell. 

Willemse, just doesn't have the brain for 10, seems to instinctive. I see Manie Libbok is at 10 for the stormers, but he is woeful. Similar to Willemse, has a killer step but that is about it. 

I think the Smith kid looks okay at the bulls but he is just a robot, does his kicks but doesn't look to take the ball flat. 

Ja,  for now I think we have Pollard, Janjties, Willemse, Frans,  Morne and Goosen. 

I would definitely bring Goosen in

If you say so, then it must be false. I wish you'd stop putting the touch of death upon young talent.

Dave

If Mozart and the Kindergarten Imbecile ever select a Springbok team - the team would struggle to be 0ranked higher than 10.    They have no idea about player performances and selections and knows zero about the game anyway.    I gave  up reading their repetitive drivel  that has been going on for a decade.

The re attacks on Erasmus is on a full time basis - bu8t when Meyer and Coetzee destroyed Springbok rugby  there was not a single word of  criticism of those two failed coaches.