FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  Who should be picked for test against Italy

Who should be picked for test against Italy

Started by Beeno18 REPLIES484 VIEWS· 10 Nov 2025, 08:19
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
BE
Beeno1Captain40,032 posts
10 Nov 2025, 08:19
#1
10 Nov 2025, 08:19#1

Obviously we want to win the game. Clearly we want our squad of 23 to play Ireland to be as fresh as possible and ready to compete.

Is it a test o experiment eg Hooker at 12. Time to give players, a chance.

One thing for sure pack your bench with your best players. Hopefully they only play 20 minutes or so.

This guy has a little You Tube Channel going and has made an interesting selection.


SA
Saffolk Captain30,741 posts
10 Nov 2025, 09:40
#2
10 Nov 2025, 09:40#2

I’d go with


15 Arendse 14 Edwil 13 Moodie 12 Hooker 11 Williams 10 Pollard 9 vd Bergh 1 Venter 2 Grobelaar 3 Porthen 4 Kleyn 5 RG 6 v Staaden 7 BJ Dixon 8 Kwagga


16 Marx 17 Steenkamp 18 Wilco 19 Eben 20 Wiese 21 Libbok 22 Willemse 23 Esterhuizen

SA
Saffolk Captain30,741 posts
10 Nov 2025, 09:51
#3
10 Nov 2025, 09:51#3

Beeno that stupid prick does not even know the difference between a 1 and 3 and I doubt Esterhuizen will play 6 more than likely 7!

XA
XaviPro1,924 posts
10 Nov 2025, 11:28
#4
10 Nov 2025, 11:28#4

Good side Saffex,


I'd definitely rest Eben, Jasper and PSDT. Maybe RG too. Mostert can partner Kleyn with RG and Nortje on the bench. Id start Hooker at 11 and let Willemse have a run at 12. Williams off the bench. Starting Willams on the wing means if he has to go to 9 for Morne, He's going to play a full game and that's a lot of wear and tear on him, especially with Ireland looming.

CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
10 Nov 2025, 14:12
#5
10 Nov 2025, 14:12#5

15 Van der Merwe. 14 Hooker, 13 Moodie, 12 Willemse, 11 Arendse, 10 Pollard. 9 Van den Berg, 8 Kwagga,

7 Du Toit (captain), 6 Esterhuizen, 5 Mostert, 4 Kleyn, 3 Porthen, 2 Grobbelaar, 1 Steenekamp


16 Van Staaden, 17 Ntlabakanye, 18 Louw, 19 Etzebeth, 20 Kolisi, 21 Dixon, 22 Williams, 23 Libbok


Libbok and Arendse were pahetic on Saturday and they need game time. So does Etzebeth as well.



SA
Saffolk Captain30,741 posts
10 Nov 2025, 15:02
#6
10 Nov 2025, 15:02#6

Bullshit were they pathetic


A charge down against Libbok but that first one was because he had time taken off him. He received the pass behind him, had to turnaround and then make the kick.


Arendse’s poor awareness and intensity in defending that Penaud first try

CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
10 Nov 2025, 16:34
#7
10 Nov 2025, 16:34#7

Two charge downs - not one. One can be overlooked - two is serious BS.

SA
Saffolk Captain30,741 posts
10 Nov 2025, 17:06
#8
10 Nov 2025, 17:06#8

Oh what utter shit - he was good bar one charge down


No one is fucking stupid enough to define a players performance by one charge down

CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
10 Nov 2025, 18:03
#9
10 Nov 2025, 18:03#9

L:isten maybe you missed the second charge down. One can be excused - two represents BS . I never said he should be dumped from the squad -I said he needs more game time. He had some good matches - and I suported him as second choice flyhalf. Pollard is rapidly approaching retirement and, In the Ede Prk test abd int eh Bulls URC match he shoed signs o deficiencies,


The flyhalfs I rate for t he future are -


1 Sacha

2 Libbok and

3 Matthee,

— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby