Rassie Erasmus, the mastermind behind the Springboks' recent strategies, has been pioneering a forward-heavy bench, frequently opting for a 6-2 split between forwards and backs. This strategy diverges significantly from New Zealand’s traditional 5-3 bench setup. Under Ian Foster's tenure, a 6-2 split was a rarity, and Scott Robertson maintained a conservative approach, strictly adhering to the 5-3 setup throughout his leadership.
However, Read believes that matching the physicality and impact of the Springboks' bench is essential for the All Blacks' success. He pinpointed the impressive performances of rookie Anton Segner as a testament to the potential benefits of tactical boldness in team selection.
"If I look at how Segner played against Italy, he deserved the opportunity to be in that 23 for Ireland and I actually feel he was probably one of our better loose forwards – if you look at impacts. He’s making a great play for himself to say, ‘Hey, look, I need to be in here in some way, shape or form.'"
Dave Rennie is seemingly warming up to the idea of experimenting with a heavier bench in upcoming matches. Such a move could align well with the dynamic presence of players like Damian McKenzie, who offers versatility in the backline, potentially reducing the need for a traditional backline setup on the bench.
Former All Black Justin Marshall highlighted the strategic flexibility that a player like Anton Lienert-Brown offers, capable of covering multiple positions in the backline, which can be pivotal in high-pressure game scenarios.
"So, we’ve got to be really bold with those selections and actually make the selections and be bold to make the substitutions when it matters."
Meanwhile, South Africa continues to leverage the versatility of players like Andre Esterhuizen, who has been a game-changer by effectively playing both as a centre and flanker. This kind of strategic flexibility gives the Springboks an edge, particularly in the latter stages of a game when fresh legs and varied skills sets can turn the tide of the match.
The loss of Leicester Fainga’anuku due to injury is a significant blow for the All Blacks, as he is a player who, much like Esterhuizen, could cover multiple roles from the bench. His ability to play both in the backs and as a forward could have offered New Zealand a similar strategic advantage.
As the All Blacks gear up for their next series of matches in South Africa, the selection and utilization of their bench will be crucial. Whether Rennie decides to stick with the traditional split or opts for a more adventurous approach could very well dictate the pace and outcome of the games.
In the end, the effectiveness of the All Blacks' strategy will hinge not just on who they bring off the bench, but when and how they deploy these players. The ongoing debate between tradition and innovation continues to add an intriguing layer to the already complex and thrilling game of rugby.
