FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / CRICKET /  My best SA side

My best SA side

Started by Saffolk 12 REPLIES2,000 VIEWS· 15 Aug 2019, 23:37
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
SA
Saffolk Captain30,741 posts
15 Aug 2019, 23:37
#1
15 Aug 2019, 23:37#1
1. Richards 2. Smith 3. Amla 4. AB 5. Kallis 6. G. Pollock 7. de Kock 8. S. Pollock 9. Rabada 10. Steyn 11. Donald No place for a spinner as none are worthy Close call between Boucher and de Kock
MO
MozartCaptain49,914 posts
16 Aug 2019, 00:30
#2
16 Aug 2019, 00:30#2
Hugh Tayfield was arguably the best spinner in the world for 3 years. Rabada would go and Quintie whose keeping and batting in the WC were not All Star standard. I would bring in Mike Proctor in place of Rabada. And Tayfield in place of Quint....AB is a perfectly fine keeper. If you want a specialist keeper, Boucher or Johnny Waite were much superior. And Graham Pollock should bat at 5.
SA
Saffolk Captain30,741 posts
16 Aug 2019, 01:06
#3
16 Aug 2019, 01:06#3
Boucher had fight in him but de Kock is more talented and flamboyant so I’m going with Quin. As good as Pollock was I just can’t see Kallis at 6. I think Rabada will end up being even better than Steyn and Donald were so he is a definite for me Tayfield and Keith Oxlee were my father in laws lawn bowling partners back in the day in Durban
CH
ChippoPro3,372 posts
16 Aug 2019, 01:33
#4
16 Aug 2019, 01:33#4
I never got to see the likes of Richards and pollock unfortunately. Post isolation team: Smith Gibbs Kirsten Hash Kallis AB QDK Pollock Steyn Ntini Donald
CH
ChippoPro3,372 posts
16 Aug 2019, 01:34
#5
16 Aug 2019, 01:34#5
My only iffy pick is ntini over robharder
SA
Saffolk Captain30,741 posts
16 Aug 2019, 01:55
#6
16 Aug 2019, 01:55#6
Rabada is far superior to Ntini no contest Kirsten was good but not great.
MO
MozartCaptain49,914 posts
16 Aug 2019, 04:40
#7
16 Aug 2019, 04:40#7
Nobody was more elegant than Pollock, his cover drive has to be in the mix as the greatest stroke in the history of the game.
SA
Saffolk Captain30,741 posts
16 Aug 2019, 10:39
#8
16 Aug 2019, 10:39#8
Yeah I did not see much of him and Richards - i was too young!!
CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
16 Aug 2019, 17:29
#9
16 Aug 2019, 17:29#9

I saw Pollock play at Wanderers in a test against the Ausies in 1969/70.   I also saw Barlow that day bowling to the Aussie captain - Bill Lawry,

First ball he played and missed and the second and third one the same.  So Barlow  walked over to him and handed him his glasses.  The fourth ball he clean-bowled him,  I will never forget that one.

       

AJ
AJHPro3,183 posts
06 Oct 2019, 17:57
#10
06 Oct 2019, 17:57#10

I had the honor of bowling to Pollock while doing my ACF stint in Bloemfontein.

He was serving in the Armoured Car Regiment at that time and he was a very gifted stroke player and a class guy all round.

Richards, Smith,  Gibbs, Kallis, Pollock, AB, Boucher, Tayfield, Proctor, Steyn, Donald.

12th Man would be either Colin Bland or Jonty Rhodes.






JA
JarheadRookie89 posts
06 Oct 2019, 21:14
#11
06 Oct 2019, 21:14#11

Sorry saffex...

that side wont do.

Not enough natives!

CL
CleanCutPro9,905 posts
24 Nov 2019, 12:41
#12
24 Nov 2019, 12:41#12

What ... no Clive Rice ... no Gary Kirsten ... no Gibbs??

Amla? You're kidding right?

Radebe ... lol!!!

Typical Stupid Dave.

I see you're just as confused in cricket.

Best you leave all sport alone, boy .



DE
DennyCaptain12,893 posts
25 Nov 2019, 07:35
#13
25 Nov 2019, 07:35#13

Not having seen the all stars 60's Protea side makes it nigh impossible to compare and select the best ever South African side. I'm happy to go with the opinions of those who know and understand the game, ex players like Bill Lawry, Ian Chappell, and the late Tony Greig etc. I can't remember a time Graeme Pollock's name didn't pop up in commentary when the Proteas toured down under.

On that basis Richards and Graeme Pollock is a must but then what about Eddie Barlow, Colin Bland and Peter Pollock who were both voted Wisden Cricketer of the Year, and let's also not forget Clive Rice, Vincent van De Bijl probably one or two that I've missed.

Post Apartheid, Donald, Shaun Pollock, Steyn, Amla and Kallis is at the top of my list.

Smith was technically flawed and would not make my best side.

— END OF THREAD —

More from Cricket