MOMozart
Captain49,914 posts
MOMozartCaptain49,914 posts
23 Dec 2018, 01:55#2
Denny I wouldn't have taken on this issue right now, but mostly because there is just too much going on. Right now things have a chaotic feel and the stock market plunge is adding to it.
That said, the Generals never want to leave and the only country we really left, Vietnam, has done just fine. And this deification of Mattis, which reminds one of the sudden appreciation for Bush senior and McCain, seems a little over the top.
These are the same generals who desperately wanted to take on Iraq, the single most disastrous foreign policy decision since getting into Vietnam.
Mattis, by the way was a director of the failed company Theranos .....and presumably totally duped by the 27 year old CEO Elizabeth Holmes. He wasn't much of an adult in the room in that instance. Read the book, Bad Blood, it's fascinating.
The argument about the Kurds, history's victims, has some real resonance though. One can only hope whatever deal Trump has worked out with Turkey rewards them for their efforts. But that's hard to believe given the historical emnity between Turkey and the Kurds.
So it doesn't look so good, but to date, eg on the wire-tapping assertion, Trump has generally had some facts that have eluded the media . So I'm not convinced either way.
MOMozart
Captain49,914 posts
MOMozartCaptain49,914 posts
23 Dec 2018, 20:49#4
But Denny this is the same kind of group think that got us into Iraq. Our presence in Syria wont make it less radical....it will ultimately become part of the problem. We have to learn how to intervene if it's absolutely necessary, but then get out.
It's ironical that a number of Obama era voices are now dumping on Trump for leaving Syria, when Obama steadfastly refused to even react to the chemical attacks.
Still that's not going to stop the angst. What will, will be the appointment of a respected military man with gravitas to replace Mattis. Let's hope he gets that right.
The Kurds I concede are a separate issue and they need to be protected. But it's sickening to see how many talking heads have now suddenly discovered the plight of the Kurds,