Bokrapport -: Rating of Players

Bokeapport,com is running a programme where the public can rate players according to the scale 1 to 10 and the situation thus far is as follows:-
Zane Krichner
My own rating              =      3General public rating      =      3Rapport Rating              =      4
Lwazi Mvovo 
My own rating              =      4  General public rating      =      5Rapport Rating              =      5
Jesse Kriel
My own rating             =       5General public rating     =       5Rapport Rating             =       5
Jean de Villiers
My own rating             =       3General public rating     =       3
Rapport Rating             =       3
Bryan Habana 
My own rating             =       4 General public rating     =       4Rapport Rating             =      5
Pat Lambie
My own rating             =       5General public rating     =       5Rapport Rating            =       4

Ruan Pienaar
My own rating             =      2General public rating     =      2Rapport Rating            =      4
Schalk Burger
My own rating             =      4General public rating     =      5Rapport Rating            =      4
Pieter-Steph du Toit
My own rating            =       5General public rating    =       5Rapport Rating            =      4
Francois Louw
My own rating            =       3General public rating    =       5Rapport Rating           =       5
Victor Matfield
My own rating            =       2General public rating    =       4Rapport Rating            =      3
Lood de Jager
My own eating            =      7General public rating    =      7Rapport Rating            =      7
Jannie du Plessis

My own rating            =      3       General public rating    =      3Rapport Rating            =     3
Bismarck du Plessis
My own rating            =      3General public rating    =      4Rapport Rating            =     5
Tendai Mtawarira 
My own rating             =      3  General public rating     =      4Rapport Rating            =       4
Trevor Nyakane
My own rating             =      5  General public rating     =      4Rapport Rating            =       5
Coenie Oosthuizen 
My own rating            =        1General public rating    =        2Rapport Rating            =        1
Eben Etzebeth
My own rating            =        5General public rating    =        5Rapport Rating            =        5
Siya Kolisi 
My own rating            =        4General public rating    =        5Rapport Rating            =       6
Fourie du Preez
My own rating            =        5General public rating    =        5Rapport Rating            =       6
Handre Pollard            =         
My own rating            =        6General public rating    =        6Rapport Rating            =       6
JP Pietersen 
My own rating            =        2General public rating    =        4Rapport Rating           =         5
Lets forget about what individuals such as rugby writers in Rapport and myself say about the  ratings and look at what the General Public say about the ratings: -
*    According to the above the  General Public finds the following players to have failed in the test last Saturday:-
     Kirchner, Habana, De Villiers, Pienaar, Matfield, Jannie, Bismarck, Mtawarira, Nyakane, Oosthuizen, Pietersen
*    All the above is regarded as more experienced players
*    According to the above none of the less experienced players in fact failed in the test.
We have for days been entertained by Mozart and Desert Fox with wild stories about none of the experienced players failing and the failures were Oosthuizen, Lambie and  Kriel.   However, it is generally stated by them that nobody bar themselves are rugby fundi and that they are always correct.  We can accept that they would say the public knows nothing about rugby and their assessments are all that counts.

 same old...

 Denny
I think that it is interesting to see what the generl public thinks about the players and the performance of players.   We gets caught up in differences of opinion on this site  and our focus is more restricted than the general SA Rugby fans think.    

 A defintive assessment
Zane KrichnerBeeno                         =     3My own rating              =      3General public rating      =      3Rapport Rating              =      4
Lwazi Mvovo B                              =       4My own rating              =      4  General public rating      =      5Rapport Rating              =      5
Jesse KrielB                                       6My own rating             =       5General public rating     =       5Rapport Rating             =       5
Jean de VilliersB                                =     4My own rating             =       3General public rating     =       3
Rapport Rating             =       3
Bryan Habana B                              =      5My own rating             =       4 General public rating     =       4Rapport Rating             =      5
Pat LambieB                               =      5My own rating             =       5General public rating     =       5Rapport Rating            =       4

Ruan PienaarB                               =     3My own rating             =      2General public rating     =      2Rapport Rating            =      4
Schalk BurgerB                               =      6My own rating             =      4General public rating     =      5Rapport Rating            =      4
Pieter-Steph du ToitB                                 =   5My own rating            =       5General public rating    =       5Rapport Rating            =      4
Francois LouwB                              =      5My own rating            =       3General public rating    =       5Rapport Rating           =       5
Victor MatfieldB                               =      0My own rating            =       2General public rating    =       4Rapport Rating            =      3
Lood de JagerB                              =      8My own eating            =      7General public rating    =      7Rapport Rating            =      7
Jannie du Plessis
B                              =      4My own rating            =      3       General public rating    =      3Rapport Rating            =     3
Bismarck du PlessisB                              =      4My own rating            =      3General public rating    =      4Rapport Rating            =     5
Tendai Mtawarira B                               =     4My own rating             =      3  General public rating     =      4Rapport Rating            =       4
Trevor NyakaneB                               =      4My own rating             =      5  General public rating     =      4Rapport Rating            =       5
Coenie Oosthuizen B                              =        1My own rating            =        1General public rating    =        2Rapport Rating            =        1
Eben EtzebethB                              =        6My own rating            =        5General public rating    =        5Rapport Rating            =        5
Siya Kolisi B                              =        2My own rating            =        4General public rating    =        5Rapport Rating            =       6
Fourie du PreezB                              =        5My own rating            =        5General public rating    =        5Rapport Rating            =       6
Handre Pollard            =         B                              =        7My own rating            =        6General public rating    =        6Rapport Rating            =       6
JP Pietersen B                              =        4My own rating            =        2General public rating    =        4Rapport Rating           =         5
Now everyoine knows what the correct rating should be.Ou maaaikie please ammend accordingly!

Actually, the players who have failed us most this World Cup are Steph, Lambie, Bismarck, Kriel and to a lesser extent Pienaar and Jean.

 Card please get a grip on reality. Yo say daft things like Damian nbeing a weak center. he si the most powerful center we have barring perhaps Eesterhuizen.Its comments like this that give your cred a dent. Supprting matfield ahead of Lood etc etc.  
The use of spacing and paragrapghs would help decipher your threads

I hope you and Mz return to sanity soon - its been a long time off the tracks! Youa re making ou maaaikei look good!

 Card please get a grip on reality. Yo say daft things like Damian nbeing a weak center. he si the most powerful center we have barring perhaps Eesterhuizen.Its comments like this that give your cred a dent. Supprting matfield ahead of Lood etc etc.  
The use of spacing and paragrapghs would help decipher your threads

I hope you and Mz return to sanity soon - its been a long time off the tracks! Youa re making ou maaaikei look good!

 DF
I do not think that most SA Rugby Fans are the stooges you believe they are.  They cl;early saw what happened in the game last weak.   Theys aw the problems - not through media direction  - nor through prejudice.  
Morne has given away a number of tries due to putrid defense or thoughtless play and poor execution - so he is the biggest failure by flyhalf during the professional era.         Your observations are normally so influenced by prejudice against certain players - they are effectively worthless.   I can name a long string of such misinterpretations and you and Mozart never see what a player like Victor in fact does,   he can never be found where a lock is supposed to be and is moonlighting in the backline - where he can add up weak and ineffective tackles as his only contribution to the game.   People in fact saw and realized on Saturday how he was absent from the forwards battles.  They saw how Du Toit helped in scoring of two rolling maul tries and how Matfield played zero role in that.   You and Mozart saw none of that - because you preferred not to see what happened - or if in fact you did see it, both of you decided not to mention it at all, because you wanted to have a go at Du Toit.
Your disdain of people who does not subscribe to you ideas is disgusting and is really laughable.