A biological male can never be female.
Is Imane Khelif male, if so what makes him male? Is it simple the presence of the X Chromosome?
So why doesn’t the organisation’s make a league for these DSD people or trans ? Problem solved and they can have there own little club where they can do what they want to. Keep them separate from real woman!!
Because there isn't enough of them to have their own competition. There has only been one ever trans athlete to compete at the Olympics' and there is no trans people competing in the Paris Olympics, and just two that may be people with DSD or are intersex, both of them boxers but in different weight categories so they wouldn't be fighting against each other anyway. With DSD there is also the matter in that it can manifest itself in different ways affecting some people in a very minor way to having much more significant affects on others, so then if you where considering that there should be a DSD category only, how much does a person have to be affected by DSD before they are put into that category, who decides that. Complete rabbit hole. In affect separate categories for trans or DSD people would be a defacto ban.
Fact is this Algerian is not a biological woman and should not be fighting or competing against any real woman!
We don't know that's a fact. The President of the IBA told Russian state media that the tests had proved Imane Khelif has XY Chromosomes, but the testing methodology was never stated nor any evidence published proving that. Why would one favour the IBA's unknown testing system over the IOC's system?
What about that trans gender swimmer Lia Thomas competing against biological woman?? Riley Gaines luckily stood up against that…yet again if you were born a man and you want to be a women, then do what you want…. But don’t expect to be treated as a biological woman.
Riley Gaines is entitled to her opinion and she's not the only athlete with that view, but many other female athletes have came out in support of Lia Thomas. Other's took the view that trans women could compete as long as they could demonstrate they lost there sex linked male puberty advantage.
I note Riley Gaines is also against trans people taking part in women's chess competitions. Someone want to explain how a trans women would have an unfair advantage here? Kinda suggests Gaines isn't really concerned about fairness but just doesn't like trans people in general.
Then there is also a trend where men with male organs can now identify as women or a biological Women can identify as a Women, just because they feel like it??
Well its more than they just feel like it. It's not like they wake up one day and go ah you know what I feel like being trans. For most its probably a slow process of realisation that happens over time. Ultimately I don't care what someone wants to identify as. They can identify as a carrot for all I care. It's none of my business. When it comes to them competing in sport I would be favour of them competing in cases where their not advantaged by the gender they had before transitioning.
In America these kind of men that are jailed but identify as a woman all of a sudden, we’re allowed to go to female prisons….what happened was that these men raped some of the female prisoners!
Searching around I can see there is one reported case of that happening, where a man pretended to be a trans women and allegedly raped a female inmate.. Believe a court case is ongoing. There is nothing to suggest this is a widespread occurrence. And if that one case is true its not reflective of trans people. That wasn't a trans person committing a crime.