BIbiltongbek
Club Pro749 posts
BIbiltongbekClub Pro749 posts
30 Nov 2014, 16:13#2
Meyer will go for experience, he won't consider if there is an old player available, he hinted in that direction after the match, blaming inexperience
30 Nov 2014, 16:41#3
I've also wondered why Goosen has all of a sudden been removed from contention at flyhalf, he's definitely better than Lambie and is more elusive than Pollard with a bigger boot. In my mind the best SA flyhalves are between Pollard and Goosen, Lambie has become a jack of all trades master of none just like Frans Steyn.
30 Nov 2014, 16:50#4
Hanekom is looking like the biggest benefactor from the open 13 spot, he's got a fantastic opportunity to get in the Bok squad for the RC and RWC if he plays well enough in the Super 15.
BIbiltongbek
Club Pro749 posts
BIbiltongbekClub Pro749 posts
30 Nov 2014, 19:55#5
Forget about next year's world cup, select 31 young players and expose them to world cup conditions
AJArthur John
Pro1,748 posts
AJArthur JohnPro1,748 posts
30 Nov 2014, 22:42#6
Alas I just know that you are correct biltongbek.
To late I fear to turn the ship around at this stage.
SASaffolk
Captain30,741 posts
SASaffolk Captain30,741 posts
30 Nov 2014, 23:42#8
Strauss at flank......bwhaaahaaaaa......about sums Sharktwat up when it comes to rugby
BIbiltongbek
Club Pro749 posts
BIbiltongbekClub Pro749 posts
01 Dec 2014, 00:05#10
Agree Saffe x, and his team will fail.

sharkbok
Captain23,293 posts

sharkbokCaptain23,293 posts
01 Dec 2014, 02:46#13
Saffex for a laugh lets see what you believe the team should be.
How many of them have no SuperXV experience, probably half your team ?
MOMozart
Captain49,914 posts
MOMozartCaptain49,914 posts
01 Dec 2014, 04:27#14
You have to love this. A month ago we were world beaters, now we have no hope. Blikkies is right, teams can resurrect their fortunes very quickly.
AGAgPleezDeddy
Club Pro900 posts
AGAgPleezDeddyClub Pro900 posts
01 Dec 2014, 16:13#17
I like the squad saffex, only changes I would make are taking Du Preez too, and finding a place for Kriel in the squad too.I'd also like to see Kolbe given a chance but I have a feeling he'll never win a cap under Meyer.
SASaffolk
Captain30,741 posts
SASaffolk Captain30,741 posts
01 Dec 2014, 17:18#18
Yeah I'd be more than happy with Kriel in the mix, as I would Kitshoff, Hanekom, Faf de Klerk, v/d Walt, CJ Stander, Mtembu and Labascagne.....not to mention a wild card like Esterhuizen, Kobus v/Wyk or Jessie Kriel

sharkbok
Captain23,293 posts

sharkbokCaptain23,293 posts
01 Dec 2014, 19:09#19
Saffex your team is allmost the same as the team that lost to Wales, barring injured players that are not available anyway.
Take out Matfield and Jean and the team is pretty much the same as yours. JP and Habana were not available due to the test window being completed.
The other additions cant be in the squad due to a limited size. A squad has to be less than 30+- players.
CLclevermike
Coach57,555 posts
CLclevermikeCoach57,555 posts
01 Dec 2014, 20:42#21
Mozart
In a way I agree with you - that is about the 8 players you listed. My only problem is with JP - he has gone backwards so far that compeitiveness is not in his case even remotely possible. He does not compete anymore and part of the prblem is lack of pace.
There are question marks about Habana and Du Preez as well - but I can live with them. Habana is not a shadow of the player he was last year and Du Preez was not above avera ge in virtually all tests played after his return to international rugby - In their case we can only hope they recover even part of the form they displayed in the past.
Reptation is an ugly thing when it comes to team selection - and the real reason why no team has ever won the WC twice in succession. The reason remains to amny reputation selectoions without regard to performance.
Jp will be playing Super 15 for at least a major aprt of the compettition - he was dismal this year in that series - so he will ahve a chance to redeem himself. I have my doubts though - the lack of ace impediment is unlikely to allow for improvement in performance.

sharkbok
Captain23,293 posts

sharkbokCaptain23,293 posts
01 Dec 2014, 20:50#22
When Fourie Dupreez plays the Boks take the right options. He may not allways stand out but the tactics of the game are sound. He is one of the generals, and he is surely missed when Hougaard is playing the fool.
CLclevermike
Coach57,555 posts
CLclevermikeCoach57,555 posts
01 Dec 2014, 21:09#23
Sharkbok
I am not sure whether tactics are the only thing that count - execution of functions are of equal importance. The latter is where Du Preez has a problem - his lack of pace is really effecting execution. He is not by any imagination even 30 % o the player he was in 2007.
The other things that bothers me with him is the loss of pace and even doubtful fitness deficincies he displays in games. Good one weekend and quetionable the next weekend. We know that clubs in Japan plays only games twice a month - normally every 14 days - and the players returnng from there is not in peak fitness. So a reasonable question is? Can Fourie du Preez play three or more weekends in a row without a drastic drop in performance?.
I have a nagging susupicion that he may also opt out of the WC - since he had very little game time this year - was badly injured in June and his club may put pressure on him to play for them and not for the Springboks - especialluy in view of potential further injuries which could impact negatively on his club schedule. This is a serious possibility if he is not at peak fitness and play in test rugby
SASaffolk
Captain30,741 posts
SASaffolk Captain30,741 posts
01 Dec 2014, 21:53#24
Wow Shark so my side had Mvovo, Hendricks, Jean, Matfield and Oupa in it did it....not to mention Serfontein out of position at 13?
That's a third of the side that is wrong. ..so no its not almost my side. Would I start Lambie ahead of Pollard - no I would not.
So that side was practically 50% wrong.
ABABasquefan
Pro2,549 posts
01 Dec 2014, 22:21#25
@mozart,
"The AB team in 1995 was way better than ours, they proved that in the
ensuing years. But we beat them. We can beat any team in the world on
the day."
It's beyond any doubt that that AB team was way better than the bok team and that you just won because more than half of the team was food poisoned, some players were throwing up during the match and even then you need an extra time to win. If this was provoked intentionally by any SA authority or if it was accidental is another question but the fact was that the team was poisoned.
If you trust in these kind of things to happen for winning a WC means that something is going wrong with your team, something has been made wrong and this is IMO the preparation for the WC. Meyer has made some big mistakes, the main one, sticking with the geriatrics and the problems are showing now.
The boks have problems all over the squad, they have problems at the front row (Jeannie), at the second row (Matfield), at the backrow (Mohoje, Burger), you don't have any reliable scrumhalf, or anything sure about who's gonna be the flyhalf, problems at center with JdV out now for at least 8 months but probably being better for the squad that he stays longer out of the field because if not, he will be playing the WC having not played any minute of rugby during the season and hence out of form for sure, and you have problems in the outside back with le Roux having shockers every 2 or 3 games, being now Habana a shadow of what he was and no other established wing.
For sure anything could happen in a RWC and the boks could win it but even Namibia could win it, they have close to zero probabilities but they could win.
And I don't think that the way the boks are approaching the WC is the best one
02 Dec 2014, 07:35#26
Still hurting I see, Abasque.
Any old excuse will do, huh?

sharkbok
Captain23,293 posts

sharkbokCaptain23,293 posts
02 Dec 2014, 19:24#27
Abasqye fan is fro m some small country that is deportation from Spain or France. (Basque country). I dont think they even have a rugby team. It is good to know he is privy to how South Africa won in 1995 and how the Boks were dependent on this. No mention of 2007 when the Boks again won, but away from home.
CLclevermike
Coach57,555 posts
CLclevermikeCoach57,555 posts
02 Dec 2014, 20:17#29
Blikkies
I am not sure that Du Preez is on the required fitness elvel he should be. From what I have seen in games - he is not and I think being not so - add to injuries in games. He has one above average game - followied by a questionable game - it happened repeatedly in the RC last year and in all subsequent games played by him.
THis year he played about 12 games in total - for the rest he was injured. He is likely have from January to April next year a further 8 games and then 4 games in the RC next year. Is that enough to ensure that he will be at prime fitness in the WC. I do not think so.