FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  Sport24.Bok Player Ratings

Sport24.Bok Player Ratings

Started by sharkbok1 REPLIES130 VIEWS· 30 Nov 2014, 03:35
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
sharkbok
sharkbokCaptain23,293 posts
30 Nov 2014, 03:35
#1
30 Nov 2014, 03:35#1
Boks saved lamest for last!2014-11-29 22:41

Willie le Roux: 4

Started out reasonably brightly, and found some decent touches with relieving kicks. But boy, did his day dive-bomb! Got progressively more jittery, culminating in terrible knock-on near own line and under no pressure. Won’t want to revisit the video of his second half.

Cornal Hendricks: 4.5

Seems to be going backwards with increasing Bok exposure, rather than the more desired other way around. No particularly bad blunders, but in tight, ugly games like this one, just needs to dirty his jersey a bit more for the cause. Victim of very dubious yellow card, though ...   

Jan Serfontein: 6

I might be wrong, but his first carrying opportunity of any significance seemed to come around the 52nd minute! Still looks too much like an inside centre when he’s on the outside, but give him this much ... his defence was seriously urgent and committed.

Jean de Villiers: 5.5

One good in-field carry in narrow space, but otherwise still more prominent in tackling than on attack. Then came that sickening knee buckle for a player so jinxed when it comes to World Cups ... let’s wish him the very best in yet another recuperation drive.

Lwazi Mvovo: 5.5

Beaten in the air once, and sometimes looked uncertain when ball kicked behind him. But also provided at least two instances of fine, alert cover defence on the opposite wing.

Pat Lambie: 5

Why, oh why, did he choose to kick that ball ahead rather than pass after his brilliant break-out from Bok quarter? It kind up summed up his erratic day – including one especially wretched knock-on -- though there were good elements, like a beautiful long-range penalty strike. Certainly eclipsed by demonic Wales No 10, Dan Biggar.   

Cobus Reinach: 5.5

Not quite as stealthy in service or decision-making as he was a fortnight earlier at Twickenham. Boks still cry out for the No 9 assertiveness and leadership of seasoned Fourie du Preez.

Duane Vermeulen: 6.5

Typically gutsy industry from a clearly tired competitor who, in retrospect, should have been rested against limited Italy. Closely policed by Wales, but that didn’t stop him from landing the odd breakdown turnover or lineout pinch ... and once leaving Gethin Jenkins firmly on his backside as the prop challenged the ball-carrying No 8.

Oupa Mohoje: 4.5

Encouraging enough first few minutes, but then went increasingly, unacceptably AWOL in the heat of a difficult battle. No special gains on this tour; blindside berth will be up for reassessment.

Marcell Coetzee: 7

Has to be marked down just a fraction because Sam Warburton, not him, was the pilfering king in this Test match. Otherwise, though, amazingly full-blooded devotion to tottering Bok cause. Covered enormous ground and always looking to tackle or carry.

Victor Matfield: 5.5

There’s no doubting he made a nuisance of himself on Welsh lineout throw, and won at least one penalty for interference as he tried to clutch own ball. Looked a bit jaded in other departments, as you might expect of a 37-year-old South African tight forward in late November ...

Eben Etzebeth: 6.5

Not far behind Coetzee at all for unyielding defiance on a harrowing afternoon. Some big “hold-up” tackles on rampaging Welshmen, and a couple of forceful ball-in-hand raids. Guilty of the odd, exasperating fumble.

Coenie Oosthuizen: 5.5

Jury will stay out over his suitability to No 3 after a chequered day. (That was case with whole Bok scrum: some shockers, some epic ones.) Conceded at least two penalties, though also won one. Assertive on few driving opportunities.

Bismarck du Plessis: 5.5

Fairly innocuous finish to probably his most forgettable international season. His aura slipped a bit in 2014, and Cardiff sadly did little to arrest the trend. Sometimes powerful over the ball at breakdown, and at least he didn’t over-react to regular Welsh baiting.

Tendai Mtawarira: 6

Might he have stayed on for a bit longer? Withdrawn (for Trevor Nyakane) in 54th minute after one of his better games this year for leg drive and general vigour in open play.

Standout substitute:

Adriaan Strauss: 6

No special turnaround factors off the bench in this one. A couple of nice touches again by Nizaam Carr, but the replacement hooker earns the mantle for a busy last 20 minutes or so, including a priceless turnover very close to his own line with Boks desperately under the cosh. Francois Hougaard, alas, extraordinarily gaffe-prone when he got 18 minutes or so at scrumhalf.

*Follow our chief writer on Twitter: @RobHouwing

sharkbok
sharkbokCaptain23,293 posts
30 Nov 2014, 03:46
#2
30 Nov 2014, 03:46#2
My Ratings from worst to best.

---------------------------------------------------------
Totally Useless section

Oupa Mohoje.   0/10     Pathetic A quota selection that is not even a first choice SuperXV player. In a game when the Boks were totally dominated at the breakdown, the loose forwards have to take the blame. 
Louw and especially Vermuelen were involved at the breakdowns in ball protection, ball recovery and turnovers. Oupa does not have the work rate to be a loose forward. Schalk was sorely missed, as was Flouw. 
Our team will never win the World Cup in the northern hemisphere with an unbalanced backrow that contains Mohoje.  (All 3 loosies must be effective at the breakdown). No use having ball carriers, with only slow ball or no ball. 
Hougaard.  1/10How many times does he need to prove he cant play in the Northern Hemispere or/and behind a losing pack? When he came on it was pretty much game over. The opposition pack must have given each other high 5's when they saw the Circus Clown enter the game to turn it into a comedy. I doubt he will be on the flight to next years world up, but who knows....-----------------------------------------------------------
Backs

Willie le Roux: 2.5

His worst game for the Boks ever. 


Cornal Hendricks: 3.0 

Did squat.  (Cheslin Kolbe is surely a better option)


Pat Lambie: 4.0 

Does not have the kicking game required to play these type of matches. 


Jan Serfontein: 3.5 

One dimensional crash ball stuff. Solid on defense. 


Jean de Villiers: 3.5

One dimensional crash ball stuff. Solid on defense. 


Lwazi Mvovo: 4.5

Learned very quickly that he was not going to get the ball outside 2 crash balls. 

 

Cobus Reinach: 5.0

Slow and ponderous, but hey when their is Hougaard on the bench who is complaining? 

----------------------------------------------------------------


Forwards Section


Coenie Oosthuizen: 3.5

Should never have started, instead should have been an impact player. Gelginhuis should have started as a tighthead specialist prop. The Welsh scrum was not great, and perhaps we could have dominated them. In the northern hemisphere their is much more scrums, and rescrums. 


Bismarck du Plessis: 3.0

One dimensional try take on the opposition by himself. No longer a factor at the breakdown. Adrian Strauss is currently in much better form.. 


Tendai Mtawarira: 3.5

Started well but faded 


Matfield 4.0

Average to poor. 


Marcell Coetzee: 5.0

one of the few boks to deliver a reasonable performance. Need to get more involved at the breakdown. 


Duane Vermeulen: 6.0

one of the few boks to deliver a reasonable performance. One of the only Bok forwards he existed at the breakdown.


Eben Etzebeth: 6.5

best Forward for the Boks


— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news