GEgeneraltit
Pro3,164 posts
28 May 2016, 19:29#2
A pleasant surprise...good squad including Garth April who has played very well for the Sharks in Pat's absence and this makes good sense especially as Silky Hands is injured...cannot be too bad as no doubt he will be ok for later games.
BEBeeno1
Captain40,032 posts
BEBeeno1Captain40,032 posts
28 May 2016, 19:44#3
Mike has listed the quota players.
Personally I cant see how Notche and Kolisi make the squad either.. 20% of squad is quota with a quota coach as well. Compare what Alistair has achieved to Akkers and co.

sharkbok
Captain23,269 posts

sharkbokCaptain23,269 posts
28 May 2016, 20:19#4
Overall a good squad other than a few quota's to carry the bags.I am glad that very few players are playing overseas. Any close decision should go to the local player.
Backs
ScrummiesFaf de Klerk Scrumhalf Emirates LionsNic Groom Scrumhalf DHL Stormers Rudy Paige Scrumhalf Vodacom Bulls
Faf Gets a well-deserved call-up. Ruan Pienaar has been disposed of- which is good for a fresh start. Pienaar has been moulded into the ways of Hieneke Meyer- and he is not going to change.
FlyhalfsElton Jantjies Flyhalf Emirates Lions Patrick Lambie Flyhalf Cell C Sharks Garth April Flyhalf Cell C Sharks
Garth April is a decent call give that there is pretty much no one else. I suppose Jantjies is called up because he is a long term part of the squad- even though he is currently injured.
CentresDamian de Allende Centre DHL Stormers Jesse Kriel Centre Vodacom Bulls
Lionel Mapoe Centre Emirates Lions Jan Serfontein Centre Vodacom Bulls
Kriel is vey lucky to get his spot.Mapoe should geta well deserved starting spot. Surely Kriel should be carrying the bags with the quotas
Back 3Willie le Roux Fullback Cell C SharksLwazi Mvovo Wing Cell C Sharks JP Pietersen Wing Cell C SharksRuan Combrinck Wing Emirates Lions
Bryan Habana is gone. which is good news for a new start- and building for 2019
Fowards-
Front RowSteven Kitshoff Prop Bordeaux (France) Frans Malherbe Prop DHL Stormers Bongi Mbonambi Hooker DHL Stormers Tendai Mtawarira Prop Cell C Sharks Scarra Ntubeni Hooker DHL StormersTrevor Nyakane Prop Vodacom Bulls Julian Redelinghuys Prop Emirates Lions Adriaan Strauss Hooker Vodacom Bulls
Pretty much spot on. Kitshoff will be a welcome return- and he will be starting to get into his prime. Geat to see Jannie Duplessis has been exposed off. Bismaark is maybe a bit unlucky- but it is time to start building a new team.
Marx is a surprise ommision- but he is in he A team and he is still young
LocksLood de Jager Lock Toyota Cheetahs Pieter-Steph du Toit Lock DHL StormersEben Etzebeth Lock DHL Stormers
The locks chose themselves. Although having only 3 locks seems a bit light. Snyman may need to get more game time to prove he is the real deal
Loose forwardsSiya Kolisi Flank DHL Stormers Jaco Kriel Flank Emirates Lions Francois Louw Flank Bath (England)
Sikhumbuzo Notshe Flank DHL StormersDuane Vermeulen No 8 Toulon (France) Warren Whiteley No 8 Emirates Lions
Not bad. I am glad Nizaam karr is not in the squad. He was a one season wonder.
Schalk is gone- but he is injured. I think it is time to move on from Schalk. All the opposition know to expect the carry up by SchalkVermeulen is fortunate to be in the squad- given he will never make it to the next world cup.
Kolisi would not be my choice. He seems to be a totally independent in what he does instead of following a game plan. What he does is good- but his overall work rate is not high enough
28 May 2016, 20:37#5
A little disappointed that Ackers didn't make the squad. Let's face it, he's far superior to the two Stormers hookers.
Clearly quota picks.
Over all, not to shabby.
DEDenny
Captain12,893 posts
29 May 2016, 02:40#6
Fair and balanced comments, Sharkbok. There isn't anything I could add other than to say I'm glad Pienaar and Habana have been left out and that Whiteley has been given another shot. Pretty bold move to have included Garth April who might surprise a few, I'm on record for saying that he's shown some good touches and is a work in progress. I would have left out Willie Le Roux and JP Peterson, the latter be far too slow and old come the next RWC. A few quotas but hey, can't knock the coach, it's a numbers game.
29 May 2016, 16:54#7
Cant see you guys having too many problems doing over the wee Irish chaps with that team .Good luck to your boys for the tests ,some NH heads need deflating from what I see in NH forums .
JWJust_win
Captain18,570 posts
JWJust_winCaptain18,570 posts
29 May 2016, 17:03#8
Looks like a good Bok squad, should help reduce the levels of anguish we have heard since the RWC.
I agree Wardad, Boks should be able to handle the Irish, I look forward to hearing SA fans chest-beating, it should result in better banter
AGAgPleezDeddy
Club Pro900 posts
AGAgPleezDeddyClub Pro900 posts
30 May 2016, 04:15#9
I'm happy with the squad, to be honest. There's some bad calls in there obviously such as Ntubeni/Mbonambi included at the expense of Marx. Unfortunately I don't think Coetzee had the choice on some, as his hands were tied in meeting certain criteria.
On the whole though, a step in the right direction...let's see what we get on the pitch though!
DBDbDraad
Captain26,388 posts
DBDbDraadCaptain26,388 posts
31 May 2016, 09:35#10
PSDT out injured...Hamstring, out 2 to 6 weeks. Replaced by Mostert in the Bok squad.