FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  Stormers exit and…

Stormers exit and…

Started by Mozart69 REPLIES7,718 VIEWS· 09 Jun 2024, 04:08
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
DA
Devil's AdvocatePro7,008 posts
11 Jun 2024, 13:14
#41
11 Jun 2024, 13:14#41

I don't rate DDA now at all, and I have said that for a while now already, but that is just my own personal opinion on this topic.

I again decided to ask ChatGPT who the most dominant number 12 has been since 2014, and the reason I asked ChatGPT, is because I think it's best to take the emotion out of it, and ask a possible or potentially non-biased source.

I asked..... "Since 2014 who has been the most dominant number 12 in international rugby"

ChatGPT replied:

Since 2014, the most dominant number 12 in international rugby has been Owen Farrell of England. Here’s an analysis of his and other key players' impact in the number 12 position:

Owen Farrell (England)

  • Versatility: Although he often plays fly-half, Farrell has been crucial at inside centre, providing a second playmaking option.
  • Leadership: As England's captain from 2018 to 2023, he led the team to significant achievements, including a Six Nations Grand Slam in 2016 and a runner-up finish in the 2019 Rugby World Cup.
  • Skills: Known for his tactical kicking, solid defense, and goal-kicking prowess.
  • Consistency: Over the years, Farrell has consistently performed at a high level, making him indispensable to the English team.

Other Contenders

Damian de Allende (South Africa)
  • Physicality: Known for his powerful running and defensive solidity, De Allende has been a cornerstone of the Springboks’ midfield.
  • Achievements: Key player in South Africa’s 2019 Rugby World Cup-winning team, and consistently strong performances in the Rugby Championship and British & Irish Lions series.
  • Impact: Vital in breaking defensive lines and creating space for his teammates.
Ma’a Nonu (New Zealand)
  • Career Span: Though his peak was earlier, Nonu remained influential until his international retirement after the 2015 World Cup.
  • Attributes: Renowned for his combination of power, speed, and playmaking abilities.
  • Legacy: Played a crucial role in New Zealand's 2015 World Cup win, cementing his status as one of the all-time greats.
Samu Kerevi (Australia)
  • Aggression: Known for his aggressive ball-carrying and offloading ability.
  • Versatility: Capable of playing both 12 and 13, adding dynamism to Australia’s backline.
  • Development: Has developed into a key leader and offensive threat for the Wallabies.
Bundee Aki (Ireland)
  • Consistency: A solid presence in the Irish midfield, contributing to their Six Nations successes.
  • Defensive Prowess: Strong tackler and disruptive force in the defensive line.
  • Cohesion: Integral to the team’s tactical setup, especially in phases of structured play.

Conclusion

While other players like Damian de Allende and Ma’a Nonu have had significant impacts, Owen Farrell’s combination of leadership, tactical acumen, and consistent high-level performance makes him the most dominant number 12 in international rugby since 2014. His influence extends beyond his playing skills to his role as a leader and playmaker in crucial matches.

BE
becsPro4,378 posts
11 Jun 2024, 13:17
#42
11 Jun 2024, 13:17#42

Oh well, that was a shock !! 

RO
RooinekCaptain18,117 posts
11 Jun 2024, 13:19
#43
11 Jun 2024, 13:19#43

"Maybe Moz can confirm if these stats hold any water..... I know that's his speciality"

LMAO!

Based on the laughable tripe that Moffie comes up with when he attempts to interpret a statistic, I'd say he's the least qualified person on this board (after ou Maaik which should go without saying) to comment on anyone else's statistical conclusions.

If that's the Merkel/Moffie/Mavis complex's speciality then I'd hate to see its weakness.

But hey, DumbAss, if you can't spot Moffie's bullshit by now then you probably can't spot Bozo's bullshit either . . . oh . . . hang on . . .

RO
RooinekCaptain18,117 posts
11 Jun 2024, 13:23
#44
11 Jun 2024, 13:23#44

I'm no DDA fan but I reckon if I had to choose between him and Owen Farrell, I'd take him every day of the week.

PL
PlumCaptain21,007 posts
11 Jun 2024, 13:41
#45
11 Jun 2024, 13:41#45
I liked most of Owen's rugby. What I don't like is the man. And that's probably down to his environment. I firmly believe that he was allowed to get away with the fake tough guy act in the England squad and that made him unlikeable. That stupid "people's eyebrow" thing he did...cringe to the max. The way one could tell l that he was trying to speak on the deepest voice possible when interviewed. Reminded me of that chick Elizabeth Homes from Theranos haha Were he a Bok, a Kiwi, or an Ozzie, my feeling is that he would have been made to drop the act. More so for the Boks and ABs than Oz, but none of those sides allow much arrogance or fakeness. To the point where they're almost monotonous in how humble they are. Take Eben for example, compare him to Itoje, Pollard to Farrel...you see what I'm getting at. Not a single Bok would refuse to hang the silver medal around their necks had they lost in 2019. It's stuff you don't do if you're in a team that focuses on being real, being humble. And letting your rugby do your talking. But despite all of that, Owen has a good record, one of the best ever for England and it's unfair and toxic to mix up his record up with one's perception of him. Now DDA on the other hand, he has no record and looks like he struggles to tie his shoes alone.
MO
MozartCaptain49,914 posts
11 Jun 2024, 13:48
#46
11 Jun 2024, 13:48#46

This chart shows the number of tries scored by rugby position in the 2019 Rugby World Cup.

MO
MozartCaptain49,914 posts
11 Jun 2024, 13:56
#47
11 Jun 2024, 13:56#47

So what do we conclude….inside center is the lowest try scoring position in the backline, ranking 8 out of 15. It would be interesting to see try creating stats as well. One would imagine this would be higher. But not for Dud….can anybody remember him actually creating a try for another player. I can’t.

And the comparison between Dud and his main contemporaries which I provided above confirms….he simply doesn’t score tries. For no more esoteric a reason than he isn’t alert to opportunities.

This lack of awareness affects his attacking play where he often lags the movement….and his defensive play. Has anybody ever seen Dud shoot up to make a spot tackle when an overlap is threatening.

He simply doesn’t see the field.

DA
Devil's AdvocatePro7,008 posts
11 Jun 2024, 13:57
#48
11 Jun 2024, 13:57#48

"But hey, DumbAss, if you can't spot Moffie's bullshit by now then you probably can't spot Bozo's bullshit either . . . oh . . . hang on . . ."

Unlike you Piss Mint.... who always makes every single thing very personal and ugly....and drags any conversation down to gutter level..... I can at l east put any personal differences aside and actually acknowledge someone's specific expertise in any field, including you..... 

RO
RooinekCaptain18,117 posts
11 Jun 2024, 14:53
#49
11 Jun 2024, 14:53#49

"I can at least put any personal differences aside and actually acknowledge someone's specific expertise in any field, including you..... "

Spare me the judgmental and self-righteous lecture, Dumbass, I'm not joking. 

I think Moffie is the worst user of statistics on this board. Of course I think he's a pompous ass and a shameless braggart, that's not why I think he's useless with statistics. It's because he's a biased fool whenever it comes to any kind of statistic.

MO
MozartCaptain49,914 posts
11 Jun 2024, 16:19
#50
11 Jun 2024, 16:19#50

So let’s compare….

I did Advanced statistics for my PhD from a leading business school, got an A grade. 

Did the optimization sequence for the same degree, including advanced calculus needed in advanced stats, got an A for all three courses, as I did for every other course….the only student to do so.

Used statistics extensively in my PhD thesis

Used statistics to direct billions of dollars of capital investment as a management consultant for major US companies

Taught Fortran programming to MBA students at the same institution

……

Every word of that is true. I reveal this only because of what you wrote not because I wanted to after all this time. Now tell us about your statistical credentials

SA
Saffolk Captain30,741 posts
11 Jun 2024, 19:51
#51
11 Jun 2024, 19:51#51
So what we get from this is that DA is highly rated - second on that list He has made world side of the year a few times and Rassie’s go to at 12 despite the competition from Esterhuizen, Serfotein and JVR We also get that a number of posters on here are blind to the merits of DA, stupid enough to judge him on the merits of how 12’s played a decade ago. Blind to the fact that all the other present test 12’s out there play it the same way DA does One would swear that all these 12’s create for those around them - absolute bullshit it simply does not happen
PL
PlumCaptain21,007 posts
11 Jun 2024, 21:57
#52
11 Jun 2024, 21:57#52
Poor RooiKnob Moz has a far better education and career than he does. I thrashed him at chess... And all that's left is a bitter twat that has zero interest in rugby and is only ever interested in trying to annoy his betters.
MO
MozartCaptain49,914 posts
11 Jun 2024, 22:35
#53
11 Jun 2024, 22:35#53
You couldn’t have been more modest about beating him, even when he used all kinds of insults. I ignored his first post about my statistics capability and only responded when he doubled down. A sad case.
DA
Devil's AdvocatePro7,008 posts
12 Jun 2024, 05:59
#54
12 Jun 2024, 05:59#54

A very sad case indeed Moz

As much as I would credit Piss Mint for anything IT related, which I would 100% do..... I credited you with your stats, given your vast knowledge and experience in this specialized field.

You see, specifically with Piss Mint, it seems that one cannot even compliment someone on this forum anymore, with what they do or have done in their lives and career, because with him, the personal issues always rise to the top of the conversation and take preference in the discussion.... every single time.

It really is quite obvious to most posters over all these years, that Piss Mint's overriding desire to drag things to gutter level and make things ugly and very personal with so many people on this forum, always overrides any possible minute urge to be civil or polite.

PL
PlumCaptain21,007 posts
12 Jun 2024, 06:26
#55
12 Jun 2024, 06:26#55
In the animal world, there's something called an extinction burst. Say for example that your dog scratches at the door when it's dinner time. Now, assume you stop feeding him when he does that because you want to stop the behaviour. What you find is that the dog will ramp up the scratching on the door at first. This is because in his mind he thinks "When previously scratched, I got fed. So twice the scratching must mean twice the food or the food will come twice as quickly." Now, look at Rooi's behaviour. He previously got a little attention when he got to it with people. But he doesn't get much any longer. Enter the extinction burst...where he now exclusively posts to be a nasty tit. Both sad and disappointing.
RO
RooinekCaptain18,117 posts
12 Jun 2024, 19:46
#56
12 Jun 2024, 19:46#56

The Servile Gimps can rally around their Massster and snap and snarl all they like, doesn't change the fact that Moffie used try-scoring as an absolute measure of an inside centre's worth and continues to panelbeat stats to discredit Pieter-Steph du Toit at every opportunity.

In both cases, we're talking about someone who either knows very little about rugby or very little about statistics . . . in Moffie's case, probably both.

I repeat . . . based on his many stupid and biased concluions reached using statistics that have little relevance, little bearing or little context . . . Moffie is the poster on this board (after Ou Maaik of course) with the least understanding of stats and how to apply them.

I realise what I'm saying here will make grovelling little suck-ups like DumbAss and ButtPlug burst into tears all over again and start shrieking about naughty old Rooinek being so mean again . . . but it doesn't change the fact that Moffie wouldn't know a relevant stat if it slapped him through his stupid fat face.

DumbAss made the point about Moffie's laughable interpretation and basically admitted that using tries scored as the sole basis for rating an inside centre is stupid . . . but he's not man enough to stand up to his Masster and argue his case . . . he'd rather just drop to his knees and assume the position than actually point out Moffie's ignorance and incompetence.

LMAO!

MO
MozartCaptain49,914 posts
12 Jun 2024, 20:45
#57
12 Jun 2024, 20:45#57

Point out where I said try scoring was the sole or even first measure of an inside center’s performance…..go ahead quote me. 

RO
RooinekCaptain18,117 posts
12 Jun 2024, 21:24
#58
12 Jun 2024, 21:24#58

Wehe . . . at least you recognise the need to distance yourself from your earlier stupidity . . . so now you'll lie, deflect, obfuscate and manipulate . . . as you always do when you get egg all over your stupid fat face . . . which is often!

LMAO!

MO
MozartCaptain49,914 posts
12 Jun 2024, 22:21
#59
12 Jun 2024, 22:21#59

You can ‘wehe’ until the donkeys come home. If you can’t provide the quote you have just turned a misleading statement into a lie. When did I ever say try scoring was the sole or even the first measure of an inside center’s performance?

PL
PlumCaptain21,007 posts
13 Jun 2024, 05:33
#60
13 Jun 2024, 05:33#60
Oh wow...RooiNuts makes an accusation, fails to provide any evidence, and then claims others lie and manipulate. Extinction burst in full swing. When it fails, that depression will sink in again and we'll not hear from him for six months.
DE
DennyCaptain12,893 posts
13 Jun 2024, 05:50
#61
13 Jun 2024, 05:50#61
Helloooo here's Buttplug on his soapbox again telling us about someone flouncing off the board...well ain't that funny......How he forgets not once but twice flouncing off the board......hard to forget the poor dear in tears on his way out.
How can anyone take him seriously.
Just get off your attention seeking soapbox, find a little corner, clamp your jaw on your Buttplug and Shut up, clown!
KI
kingcornPro3,695 posts
13 Jun 2024, 06:57
#62
13 Jun 2024, 06:57#62

What a lot of Kak jantjies never had any investment. He played over 50 test matches and then when he was peaking, threw it away with drugs and porking the dietitian while his wife sits at home with 3 young children. He had it all, great contract in Japan. He was backed by the coaches and pushing Pollard. 

They even rushed him back in, but he just got so full of himself. 

Now he is a disgraced drug cheat that noone wants to touch. 

I feel for Libbok, he is grounded young man, but you can see all over his face that he gets scared. Just like Jantjies, doesn't like contact. Libbok really struggles in the wet. He was great at the start of the world cup when the fields were dry but as soon as the fields got heavier, he folded. Pollard had to rescue him. You don't have to always play fancy rugby. 

I love watching the guy, but in tight games, I won't select him 

PL
PlumCaptain21,007 posts
13 Jun 2024, 07:20
#63
13 Jun 2024, 07:20#63

Ja, Elton was brilliant for the Lions and had some good games for the Boks, but the top end is where he fell off. That stuff on the flight from Dubai was disgraceful.

...to be fair though, that physio, I don't know how many kids I'd have to have to say no to her.

Dunno why we always have such small 10s though, from Bosch to Lambi and Manie. Can we just have one solid replacement for Pollard please? Honestly, I wouldn't mind Willemse at 10 (Brenda Fassi at 15) but we need a placekicker.

I'm betting on Hendrikse for now. He's 186cm, generally solid and looks like he can stick to a gameplan while adding just enough flair. Would like to see him at 85-87kgs though.

PL
PlumCaptain21,007 posts
13 Jun 2024, 07:21
#64
13 Jun 2024, 07:21#64

Hi Denise

Did you was those panties?

I hope so....we all do.

DA
Devil's AdvocatePro7,008 posts
13 Jun 2024, 07:28
#65
13 Jun 2024, 07:28#65

"DumbAss made the point about Moffie's laughable interpretation and basically admitted that using tries scored as the sole basis for rating an inside centre is stupid . . . but he's not man enough to stand up to his Masster and argue his case . . . he'd rather just drop to his knees and assume the position than actually point out Moffie's ignorance and incompetence."

There is nothing to stand up to you stupid moron

I was disputing what Dave said about how the game has changed in the last 5 years compared to the 5 years before that, which he kept alluding to, and if that called into question anything Moz said, then so be it.... man you are fixated hey.

I often disagree with Moz, and in your typical fashion, I once compliment him on something that he actually specializes in, and you see it as something else...... what a twat you really are.

SA
Saffolk Captain30,741 posts
13 Jun 2024, 08:42
#66
13 Jun 2024, 08:42#66
The majority of Jantjies tests were off the bench. Pollard has always started. The only time Jantjies would have started would have been when Pollard was injured So no, Jantjies had no sustained investment as a starting test flyhalf. You need that investment and time to develop into the full package. That is what happened with him at the Lions - he was brilliant for them. If he had, had that same time as a Bok he would have produced the same goods. But unfortunately for him he was behind Pollard and rightly so. Jantjies was a very handy backup and certainly a far far better rugby player than Morne ever was
PL
PlumCaptain21,007 posts
13 Jun 2024, 12:41
#67
13 Jun 2024, 12:41#67
And still, and we wait, for the evidence. ...and we wait some more. But there will be no knock at the door. Gosh, we must be prophets for surely we predicted the future. Any time now, RedSack...it's a simple copy and paste. And even though you're blinded by jealously, and stunted by your pseudo intellect...even you should be able to manage clicking ctrl + c and then ctrl + v. No? Haha you wanker.
AJ
AJHPro3,183 posts
17 Jun 2024, 17:59
#68
17 Jun 2024, 17:59#68

Morne Steyn scored more points with his boot for the Springboks than Elton or Manie.

The point is rugby is a game played to win and irrespective of how the points are earned during the game the team with the most points on the scorecoard at the final whistle is the winner.

Would be interesting to know the individual point count for the three players mentioned in Tests for the Boks.


DB
DbDraadCaptain26,388 posts
17 Jun 2024, 18:48
#69
17 Jun 2024, 18:48#69

Glasgow's victory vs Munster kinda put the Stormers match in Scotland in another perspective. 

MO
MozartCaptain49,914 posts
18 Jun 2024, 19:41
#70
18 Jun 2024, 19:41#70

No….the perspective was Manie missed every kick. Simples.

— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby