There are a number of important elements to what is going on. Those entail in the main the -
* development of rugby internally in the UK and in France; and* change in the traditional type of rugby played in the NH
Local Rugby Development
The issue here is what is the constant foreign contracts doing to enhance rugby as a game in the NH?
By contracting top players the status of club rugby is positive insofar as support for the clubs locally is concerned - they normally play in front of filled stadia and has strong community support.
However, there is a major negative - young players find their careers blocked by the foreign contracted players and the resultant impact on the national teams is seriously detrimental. There should be serious consideration given to enhance local rugby and not enough is being done in that regard.
Playing Style of Rugby
This issue came to the fore again during the recent WC. The countries who really shined bright in the WC were New Zealand, Australia and Argentina - the stampkar rugby playing countries - the UK, Ireland and South Africa were seriously defective.
Much is being made of the fact that South Africa was only beaten by 2 points by the All Blacks - but their campaign was poor and they lost badly against Japan and struggled against Wales.
The moral of the story is that the countries who played 15 man rugby and a ball-in-hand game shows all of us how rugby should really be played. The idea of trying to play off the mistakes made by opposing teams is ridiculous - because the opposition succeeds in limiting their mistakes and the stampkar players make an equal - if not more mistakes. The stampkar rugby specialize in not scoring tries - which in fact is what the game is about.
The influx of SH players - other than from SA - will definitely have an impact on the style of rugby played in the NH countries.
For the NH rugby this is indeed going to be a positive. Such a change would push SA - who thus far refuses to accept that change is necessary - further down the ranking order of rugby playing nations.


