FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  Gregor Paul: All Blacks changes far from straightforward; NZ Herald

Gregor Paul: All Blacks changes far from straightforward; NZ Herald

Started by Just_win2 REPLIES264 VIEWS· 30 Sept 2015, 13:09
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
30 Sept 2015, 13:09
#1
30 Sept 2015, 13:09#1

It's tempting to believe there has been a changing of the All Blacks guard in certain positions based on form.

Sonny Bill Williams, Charlie Faumuina and Wyatt Crockett all find themselves in a starting XV that remains - everywhere else - absolutely the top side.

Their form has been impressive in the first two games while the men they respectively replace - Ma'a Nonu, Owen Franks and Tony Woodcock - have either been quiet or a little bit off where they were expected to be.

Back in the day, this would signal a change of thinking by the selectors. In a simpler age when a starting XV was everything, that would say, given they have talked about their desire to be consistent with their selection for the remainder of the tournament, that they have seen the need to adjust their pecking orders.

But the modern game isn't so clear cut and the starting XV is no longer everything.

Nor is it possible or indeed wise, as the enormous casualty list at this tournament proves, for coaches to run the same players - particularly those in high impact positions - every test.

It doesn't work like that any more. The All Blacks don't want to be making significant personnel changes each week, but they will still have the odd player rotation depending on the state of various individuals.

The attrition at this tournament is going to be higher than anything seen before. The Tier Two nations have lifted their respective games to the point where they can, if nothing else, defend with more aggression and structure to bruise and bash the best sides and take more out of them.

The All Blacks, like every contender, are wary of that and they played five tests this year with a view to not only determining the right 31 players to take to England, but to also develop, to some extent, alternative combinations that they could use at the World Cup to protect themselves from fatigue and injury.

The midfield is a classic example - knowing as they did that they wouldn't be able to keep Nonu and Conrad Smith together for every game. They didn't do that in 2011 either - that combination was sparingly used during the pool rounds and then exclusively in the knockout stages.

That may well be the thinking again here. Williams is the man in form and he's also light on rugby this year. It wouldn't be a surprise to see him start again next week in Newcastle with Nonu at centre to give Smith a break ahead of what they hope will be three huge weeks.

Come the quarter-final, in all likelihood, the selectors will revert to the tried and trusted Nonu-Smith combination with Williams on the bench - ready to be unleashed.

There's a lot of rugby to be played and the midfield - just ask Wales - is where much of the carnage takes place. That's not to say Williams won't force his way into the starting lineup, he may be in such irresistible form that they can't keep him out, but his selection against Georgia doesn't signal that is destined to now happen.

The situation in the front-row is much the same but even less of a surprise. No prop plays 80 minutes these days and Faumuina and Crockett are starting because they both, for different reasons, need the game time.

Again, their elevation to start doesn't signal a change of thinking per se, but Franks and Woodcock will still be wary.

JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
30 Sept 2015, 13:14
#2
30 Sept 2015, 13:14#2
 SBW, Crockett, Faumuina - they all played well last week. SBW & Faumuina are both exciting to watch & I can't wait - it adds another dimension to the game.
WA
WardadPro6,663 posts
30 Sept 2015, 13:18
#3
30 Sept 2015, 13:18#3
 The ABs have revolutionized the bench in that it isnt just the guys who werent quite good enough to start but guys who add their best to the bench .And NZ seem to actually be flying under the radar what with all the pool of death bizzo .
— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news