FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  Player ratings: Australia vs South Africa

Player ratings: Australia vs South Africa

Started by Blikkies8 REPLIES451 VIEWS· 18 Jul 2015, 15:10
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
BL
BlikkiesPro1,526 posts
18 Jul 2015, 15:10
#1
18 Jul 2015, 15:10#1


ex Rugby365:


15 Willie le Roux

Played a role in both tries and showed his creative value, but his kicking game was not up to scratch and some of the 50/50 balls he threw gave possession away.6/10  14 JP Pietersen Chased high balls all day and competed fairly well, limited opportunities otherwise but worked hard off the ball.6/10  13 Jesse Kriel An impressive debut which saw him use his considerable pace in space, and show his finishing skills to take his try.7/10  12 Damian de Allende Stayed on his feet well and carried the ball in both hands as has become his trademark. Solid on defence but his option-taking was not flawless.6/10  11 Bryan Habana Made some valuable contributions despite not seeing much of the ball, beating Folau in the air for the first try and setting up Kriel for the second as well as making a vital tackle on Kuridrani.7/10  10 Handré Pollard A disappointing game which saw him make too many basic errors. Made a crucial turnover and attacked the line well, but his kicking out of hand was not good enough and he missed too many tackles.4/10  9 Ruan Pienaar His service could have been quicker, but it was a composed performance which saw him take over the captaincy. His tactical kicking was solid with most contested, but also seemed indecisive at times.5/10  8 Schalk Burger Showed that he can play at the back of the scrum, showed good control, made some big tackles and also rolled back the years by making a turnover. 8/10  7 Marcell Coetzee His World Cup looks to be in doubt due to his kne injury which is a huge blow as he has proven himself to be comfortable on both flanks. Got through plenty of work and got his team on the front foot but still some question marks over his passing.7/10  6 Francois Louw Delivered another classy performance at the breakdown in an immense defensive display. Went off and got stitched up but that did not slow him down.7/10  5 Victor Matfield Limped off with a hamstring complaint, which will have the sceptics doubting his ability to front up at the World Cup.6/10  4 Eben Etzebeth A big game from the big man who had to take on some serious responsibility with Matfield off the park. He was solid in the line-outs, made some big hits and used his power to great effect in scoring his try.8/10  3 Jannie du Plessis Answered his doubters by delivering a solid scrummaging performance, and even made some tackles as well.7/10  2 Bismarck du Plessis Made plenty of turnovers and imposed himself physically, but also made some questionable decisions, not least his charged box-kick in the 22.7/10  1 Tendai Mtawarira Very strong in the scrums and made his presence felt around the park, but also got blown up for collapsing a maul.7/10  Replacements:   16 Adriaan Strauss (On for B. Du Plessis, 49 mins) Took the ball up well, but missed a few line-outs and got blown up at scrum-time.5/10  17 Heinke van der Merwe (On for Mtawarira, 49 mins) Put under pressure in the scrums and seemed a little off the pace in the tight loose.5/10  18 Frans Malherbe (On for J. Du Plessis, 46 mins) A promising start with a few big scrums, made some important tackles but battled to make the same impact he has had in Super Rugby.6/10  19 Lodewyk de Jager (On for Matfield, 18 mins) Got through a mountain of work, taking the ball up often and tackling tirelessly. One of the bench players to impress as he stepped up under pressure in his first game back from injury.7/10  20 Teboho Mohoje (On for Coetzee, 70 mins) Was not able to impose himself, fell off a few tackles and played more like a lock than a flank.5/10  21 Cobus Reinach (On for Pienaar, 68 mins) Gave away a penalty immediately after coming on and did not add much.5/10  22 Pat Lambie (On for Pollard, 68 mins) Did not do much other than tackle with his team on the back foot.6/10  23 Lwazi Mvovo (On for Kriel, 68 mins) Limited opportunities, not able to get his hands on the ball but ran hard.6/10  By Michael de Vries.
SA
Saffolk Captain30,741 posts
18 Jul 2015, 15:14
#2
18 Jul 2015, 15:14#2
 About right.....Oupa and Heinke were crap
DB
DbDraadCaptain26,388 posts
18 Jul 2015, 15:21
#3
18 Jul 2015, 15:21#3
 Strauss 4DdA 7Bismarck 8Pollard 6 Pienaar 6.  The kicking was an instruction. 
BL
BlikkiesPro1,526 posts
18 Jul 2015, 15:33
#4
18 Jul 2015, 15:33#4

Marcell's rating is a bit low. I would have given him 8. But now with him probably out of the WC, the door is wide open for Alberts to step into 7 unopposed. God help us.


Personally I would have moved Louw to 7 and slot Jaco Kriel in at 6. Oupa Mohoje must never get even close to the squad again.  

WA
WardadPro6,663 posts
18 Jul 2015, 15:42
#5
18 Jul 2015, 15:42#5
 Pollard needs to smarten up his rather aimless kicking ,and like the Saffas around me I wasnt overly impressed with your scrum considering how much better its supposed to be compared to the Aussies ,isnt that supposed to be your big weapon ? .I think Jannie might have got an extra point based on comparison to his S15 performance .
DB
DbDraadCaptain26,388 posts
18 Jul 2015, 15:43
#6
18 Jul 2015, 15:43#6
 Agreed  on Kriel Blik. I would find a spot for Combrick too. 
DE
DezertFoxPro2,288 posts
18 Jul 2015, 15:59
#7
18 Jul 2015, 15:59#7
Yet when Lambie's kicking is aimless - worse than Pollard's showings thus far - he gets the glory for the result ala EOYT England. Disgusting. But I dang forgot, Pollard is a Bull. Suddenly it becomes so clear. Must be the reason why Hougaard is criticized for nothing, yet Pienaar's perpetually poor kicking (as well as Reinach) are merely swept under the rug. Lambie gets a 6 for being an ankle bracelet putting his backline on the backfoot! Hilarious.
CL
clevermikeCoach57,555 posts
18 Jul 2015, 16:39
#8
18 Jul 2015, 16:39#8
 Hell - Lambie is not an aimless kicker - but Disaster thinks he is.  That is the sumtotal of it.  Reinach is better than Pienaar by a mile - Disaster is more stupid than Mozart by a mile.
I wonder how Meyer managed to get 6/10.  He was on the field of play for 17 minutes - took 1 line-out - made 3 tackles or rather he assisted with three tackles - did squat for the rest.  His weakness in Tight 5 play was again highlighted - the scrums improved the moment he departed.  The Boks formed a few positive  mauls when he was gone - before that zero.  I would say 4/10 - nothing more.
 
DB
DbDraadCaptain26,388 posts
18 Jul 2015, 21:47
#9
18 Jul 2015, 21:47#9
 Fox,  wrong game,  try watching the game before trying to be clever. 
— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news