FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  Player Ratings: Silver lining, Rugby 365

Player Ratings: Silver lining, Rugby 365

Started by Just_win6 REPLIES269 VIEWS· 08 Aug 2015, 21:53
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
08 Aug 2015, 21:53
#1
08 Aug 2015, 21:53#1
silver lining

New Zealand missed out on claiming the Rugby Championships after conceding 10 late points but they still have a chance to retain the Bledisloe Cup.

They were dominated in the scrums and were kept in the game by the boot of Dan Carter and a brace from debutant Nehe Milner-Skudder, however, they could not play for the entire 80 minutes and that cost them in the end.

There is a silver lining for the All Blacks though as, four years ago, the Wallabies claimed the Rugby Championship while they went on to win the World Cup.

We rate the New Zealand players!

15 Ben Smith
Made plenty of metres when he got the chance to run while he was highly effective on defence. Grabbed a try-assist as well.
8/10

14 Nehe Milner-Skudder
A dream debut for the dynamic player as racked up 128 metres from eight carries. Throw in two tries, four beaten defender and two turnovers to light up the field.
9/10

13 Conrad Smith
Mr Consistent just goes about his business without drawing too much attention to himself but this was not one of better performances.
6/10

12 Sonny Bill Williams
Attempted his usual offloads and tricks but was not as effective as he normally would be on attack, however, he held onto all his tackles in defence.
6/10

11 Julian Savea
His defensive work needs some improving but there's no doubt he will always be a threat on attack.
5/10

10 Dan Carter
Ran the show from pivot and marshaled his backline well. Showed his experience by putting in a well-balanced performance.
6/10

9 Aaron Smith
Did himself no favours with the yellow car, however, there was no problem with the quality of service he provided as well as his tactical kicking.
7/10

8 Kieran Read
Massive effort on defence as he made 17 tackles while missing only two and stole a line-out. However, he did not offer much on attack.
7/10

7 Richie McCaw
It was another typical McCaw performance on defence and at the breakdowns.
6/10

6 Jerome Kaino
There was no way through him on defence as he held onto all 14 of his tackles while also managing to claim three line-out throws.
7/10

5 Luke Romano
Grabbed a line-out steal, a turnover and a made a few handy metres but his defensive effort left much t be desired.
5/10

4 Brodie Retallick
Bagged a couple of turnovers but his main contribution came on defensive when he managed to grab 10 tackles.
6/10

3 Owen Franks
He was dominated at scrum time, slipped two tackles and gave away as many penalties.
4/10

2 Dane Coles
Made nearly 10 metres per carry and held onto all but one tackle on defence. He once again nearly stepped his way through the defence like a backline player.
7/10

1 Tony Woodcock
Folded under the pressure from Kepu and never made any real impact in his time on the park
3/10

Replacements:

16 Codie Taylor (on for Coles, 68 mins)
Not enough time to be rated.

17 Ben Franks (on for Woodcock, 73 mins)
Not enough time to be rated.

18 Nepo Laulala (on for O.Franks, 44 mins)
His only carry gained him six metres while he missed two tackles during his stint on the field.
4/10

19 Samuel Whitelock (on for Romano, 54 mins)
Never got a feel for the ball but managed to make a few tackles.
4/10

20 Sam Cane (on for Kaino, 73 mins)
Not enough time to be rated.

21 TJ Perenara (on for A.Smith, 77 mins)
Not enough time to be rated.

22 Beauden Barrett (on for B.Smith, 61 mins)
Did not get plenty of chances but grabbed a try assist to allow Milner-Skudder to get his brace.
5/10

23 Malakai Fekitoa (on for Williams, 54 mins)
Looked to get into the game but just did not see enough of the ball.
4/10

By Tauriq Ebrahim

JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
08 Aug 2015, 21:55
#2
08 Aug 2015, 21:55#2
The team simply did not click. Let's see how it goes in Eden Park.
sharkbok
sharkbokCaptain23,282 posts
08 Aug 2015, 22:07
#3
08 Aug 2015, 22:07#3
Hehe Milner-Skid-Mark had a good game
BR
BrycyPro4,671 posts
08 Aug 2015, 22:09
#4
08 Aug 2015, 22:09#4

 ...JW the ABs were too predictable, just catch and pass...that's where Cruden is sorely missed with his dynamic attacking game...

...a line breaking centre combination with Fekitoa , Piutau or even Moala teamed up with SBW / Nonu would be an improvement..and our wings usually get more involved in the midfield than they did...Aussies forward pack outplayed us as well so need to do some adjustments there...some defensive errors otherwise it could have gone either way...

MO
MozartCaptain49,914 posts
08 Aug 2015, 22:11
#5
08 Aug 2015, 22:11#5
With those ratings you would swear the ABs were in the game. They weren't even though Phipps effectively gave them a ten point start.  
JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
08 Aug 2015, 22:16
#6
08 Aug 2015, 22:16#6
I have only watched the first 20 mins & Carter does seem slow. Not that I am blaming him for the poor performance of the team. Also, when wobblies were down a man we didn't seem to respond to take advantage of this. I sign things were not going well.
Mozart, have you watched the game yet?
CL
ClaydogClub Pro691 posts
09 Aug 2015, 14:57
#7
09 Aug 2015, 14:57#7
  Those ratings are pretty generous to some players. Like JW said they never clicked. Read only missed two tackles but both were when oz players slipped through to score. Was surprised to see oz on top in the scrums and the nz backs were not timing passes. Will be a different beast at home next week. Then we will know how us Wobblies are looking.
— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news