FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  The All Blacks' tough tactical decision, by Justin Marshall; NZ Herald

The All Blacks' tough tactical decision, by Justin Marshall; NZ Herald

Started by Just_win13 REPLIES292 VIEWS· 07 Aug 2015, 06:45
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
07 Aug 2015, 06:45
#1
07 Aug 2015, 06:45#1

You can't boil down a Bledisloe Cup test into a single tactic but what the All Blacks choose to do with the Wallabies inside defensive channel could have a massive bearing on the result.

That channel, which will be manned by Nick Phipps, Bernard Foley and Matt Giteau will be shining like a giant neon "This Way" arrow for the All Blacks, especially with Sonny Bill Williams starting at second five-eighth.

Phipps, Foley and Giteau are all courageous defenders and they'll make their tackles, but that's all they'll be able to do. They're not aggressive defenders. They just don't have the strength or height to make dominant tackles against the likes of SBW.

Expect also to see debutant Nehe Milner-Skudder come into first receiver to give them grief. As has been discussed in a previous column, Milner-Skudder is bigger and stronger than he often gets credit for and he can also find weak shoulders with his lightning footwork. he, as well as SBW, is a genuine offloading option.

With SBW, they won't be able to tackle him from the hips up. Their only option, if they're in a one-one-one situation, is the hips down and bring him to ground immediately, before that mitt extends and he throws another offload.

So this channel will be incredibly tempting for the All Blacks to continue to exploit.

But, and this is a big but, this might be a double-edged sword. There could even be an element of the Wallabies luring the All Blacks into a trap. If these guys make their tackles, and I expect they will, then lurking near that inside channel will be Michael Hooper, David Pocock and Scott Fardy. In reality, Hooper and Pocock are likely to be numbers one and two to that tackle area. once there, unless they are forced to travel backwards or laterally to the ruck, they will at best disrupt the All Blacks ball, at worst turn it over. Instead of the inside channel being the quickest route to success, it suddenly looks like a danger zone.

There's two ways of looking at what the All Blacks should do if they are disrupted by Australia's twin opensides.

One, they keep plugging away, knowing that they are at least engaging the Wallabies two most effective forwards and eventually they will tire.

From my perspective, this is the least preferred option. This is a Wallaby team that seems to be growing in self-belief daily. If that self-belief is allowed to grow in-game, then they could quickly become a very dangerous beast. If I was in the All Blacks leadership group, I wouldn't count on Pocock and Hooper bending and wilting.

Two, they adjust their tactics on the hoof and start seeking out wider channels. I would be a proponent of this. It is fair enough testing those defenders early, but if it allows Hooper and Pocock to start gaining traction, I would change quickly and certainly not wait until halftime or beyond.

Those wider channels might not be such an obvious defensive weakness of the Wallabies, but the All Blacks, especially with the way they use their tight five as ball-carriers, are still good enough to cause problems out there.

For me, this could be a test of All Blacks leadership as much as ability. There's plenty of leaders out on the park, from Richie McCaw to Kieran Read to Jerome Kaino and the Smiths, Conrad and Ben. They might need to make some tough tactical calls in what is shaping as an important test.

JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
07 Aug 2015, 06:51
#2
07 Aug 2015, 06:51#2
 Very interesting battle, sounds like a chess game. As usual it will also be about execution. Having two hyenas pursuing the inside backs & going after the ball will present an interesting challenge but if the ABs can draw the defence to SBW & he executes the offload o r simply passes the ball out wide things could really open up. 
Can McCaw, Kaino & read handle the two blondy pretty boys with the strange accents? I think they will at least do enough. ABs by 7.
BE
Beeno1Captain40,032 posts
07 Aug 2015, 08:09
#3
07 Aug 2015, 08:09#3
 JW the wooblies must not hesitate to run the ball against the many poppets in the ab backline. If the kiwis think Hooper and Pocock are pretty boys how ughly are the wee abs!!!!! Hahahahahahaha
JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
07 Aug 2015, 08:44
#4
07 Aug 2015, 08:44#4
Beeno: I may not be able to give you guidance during the games tomorrow as I will be on my way to Lithuania for a week. One hopes that your meds are well stocked & on hand - although in truth they are not very effective
BE
Beeno1Captain40,032 posts
07 Aug 2015, 08:54
#5
07 Aug 2015, 08:54#5
 JW I am off to Kleinmond so will not see the game and will have to tape them.
I am concerned the wobb;lies might burst the wee abs bubble prematurely!
Enjoy the trip to Lithuania. Now why would they be allowing an oak like you into their country!!! For what dubiou s reason
JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
07 Aug 2015, 08:59
#6
07 Aug 2015, 08:59#6
Beeno: there are rumours that I am going to Lithuania in search of moles but I cannot confirm or deny these of course
JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
07 Aug 2015, 08:59
#7
07 Aug 2015, 08:59#7
Beeno: well you will miss the live games also but as we have a record of all your usual live game statements your contribution can me imagined (intentional irony).
No doubt there will be some good banter after the game also
BE
Beeno1Captain40,032 posts
07 Aug 2015, 09:07
#8
07 Aug 2015, 09:07#8
 Jw I suspected I would not get a reason for your visit to poor Lithuania.
Be assured the kbbs will draw all the wrong conclusion and it will be hard work getting them to see sense!




JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
07 Aug 2015, 09:18
#9
07 Aug 2015, 09:18#9
Wee Justin highlights an interesting point and if the Ozzie prove tactically effective it will be interesting to see how the leadership group responds on the field.
Beeno: You must be going to Kleinmond to check out their biosphere programme, one hopes it is effective in combating global warming.
WA
WardadPro6,663 posts
08 Aug 2015, 02:36
#10
08 Aug 2015, 02:36#10
 Hey Jay-dubya ! As I recall didnt the ABS negate Po[ something naughty sounding removed] by running at him making him tackel as often as possible ? Didnt seem to bother the Highlanders much either and their line-outs might be a worry for the Wobs ,expecting Skelton to jump is like asking a Rhino to rumba .
BE
Beeno1Captain40,032 posts
08 Aug 2015, 08:28
#11
08 Aug 2015, 08:28#11
 Neither the wee abs or wobblies have adecent pack. This will be exploited by the NH men.The Oz backline looks to be superior to the wee abs.  If the oz tight five can match the pap wee abs tight five they should win.
One trust emmergency measures are in palce to deal with ou warped DUD aft er the match. bwahhahahahahaha horse and cart to take him off to the loony bin etc
Beeno honing in on the critical issue.

JW
Just_winCaptain18,570 posts
08 Aug 2015, 08:47
#12
08 Aug 2015, 08:47#12
More like: Beeno demonstrating once again a remarkable ability to misjudge talent - Oz back-line is good but not better than the ABs.
Many are concerned how the Bok line-out will go as a key player is missing a key & very experienced player. Fortunately Boks are playing a weak Argie side & Boks have the home field advantage. Boks could actually win a game, go Boks

BE
Beeno1Captain40,032 posts
08 Aug 2015, 08:55
#13
08 Aug 2015, 08:55#13
 Re the linouts eben is playing JW so no worries. Eben lood Vermulen and Burger constitute a very sound lineout. In fact the bok pack at full sttrength is awesome.
To many fancy pans oaks in the wee abs backline. Is Spieght back yet for the Wobblies?Wee abs backline should lose the collisions. Old man mcaaaw and bent read will need try and get around the park.
Sunny bill needs to show he can outrun a prop. Oz must just shut down Savea a decent player. Flatte the dud skud and hey presto!!
As I said elsewhere JW if the oz tight five can match the pap wee abs five in tights they could well win this one. Hahhaahhahahahahahaha
HA
hakwaPro4,146 posts
08 Aug 2015, 15:57
#14
08 Aug 2015, 15:57#14
 So now we know who has joined the bandwagon in giving tips to Cheika - First Robbie Deans then Daryl Gibson, then Mertens and now Justin. Also heard rumours next will be former crusaders winger. Seems to be a Crusader thing.
— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news