What is Vilas doing as our keeper

Look here ugly mug, we don't have any worthy spinners......hell Elgar our part timer looked the best of the lot. Same can be said of JP when he bowls

We don't have a worthy spinner, so yes my side sticks with Elgar and JP as my spinning options.

Find a worthy spinner and I might reconsider

Wake up idiot.....only a twat like you would select a spinner for spinners sake regardless of how good he was  

It was a shocking pitch, but sadly we don't have the spinners to really exploit any form of spinning paradise.

Our two spinners are pretty average......Harmer hardly turns it and Tahir is hardly now going to establish himself at test level aged 36.

We just don't have spinners that are significantly better than our part timers like Elgar and JP. Hell at least Elgar is a left arm orthodox meaning he turns it away from a right hander.

Until we find a genuine spinner, we are better placed sticking to our strengths with 4 seamers and 2 part time spinners, for our specialist spinners are no more than part timers.

But the biggest cock up is thinking that Vilas is a test standard keeper - what a joke. Leaving the impressive de Kock out of the squad is criminal for now the side is stuck with useless Vilas all series. Cant keep, cant bat  

"It was a shocking pitch, but sadly we don't have the spinners to really exploit any form of spinning paradise.

Our two spinners are pretty average......Harmer hardly turns it and Tahir is hardly now going to establish himself at test level aged 36."

Really?? Let's have a look shall we?

Simon Harmer(Spinner)

35 Overs

6 Maidens

112 Runs

5 Wickets

Equates to 3.2RPO

Wicket average = 22.4 Runs

Imran Tahir(Spinner)

26.3 Overs

4 Maidens

71 Runs

6 Wickets

Equates to 2.7 RPO

Wicket Average = 11.8 Runs

Philander

27 Overs

8 Maidens

61 Runs

3 Wickets

Equates to 2.25 RPO

Wicket Average = 20.30 Runs

Rabada

22 Overs

7 Maidens

49 Runs

1 Wicket

Equates to 22.27 RPO

Wicket Average =49 Runs

Wipe the Kak from your mouth.

Look here you fuck wit, I'm talking overall record you dunce.......how about adding our part time spinners match figures as well, you deceitful prick

Their figures were no better than our part time spinner, Elgar in the same test you profoundly stupid pair.

Which serves to prove my point......we don't need average specialist spinners when our part timers who can bat can do the same job. Had JP been fit, no doubt his figures would have been just as good.

My test side stands........game set and match  

Well obviously Elgar is not going to feature in my original post you fucking dunce......I just picked a side.....you were the ignorant twat who questioned my lack of a specialist spinner or two........Elgar featured in response......where I clearly pointed out that our part timers are as good as our specialists, so why bother with specialist and deprive yourself of a bat or two.

My evaluation of Harmer and Tahir is not going to centre on one game you idiot......I am not Moffie who has the gift of defining players based on one game - this idiot has now defined de Kock's keeping abilities based on a missed run out - failing to take into account the misdirected throw that effectively yorked de Kock on receipt, not to mention the skidding outfield......but given Moffie's meaure, he no doubt cannot rate AB as a fielder as AB missed a sitter of a run out in the very same game.

Back to the point, Elgar proved in the same test that he was just as good as Harmer and Tahir..........evidencing my theory that Tahir and Harmer are no better than our part timers.......but you are too fucking stupid to pick up on this obvious fact......instead you would prefer to play two average spinners at the expense of two of our class seamers. SA never play with two specialist spinners for a reason......our strength is seam regardless of pitch, coupled with the fact that we have no quality spinners. Do you think the WI in their prime would have played 2 spinners in India huh - NO, I doubt even one would have made their team.

Try catch a fucking wake up

Ah yeah Moffie and it was clearly evidenced that JP had a marginally worse strike and run rate than our specialist spinner Pietersen in that WC......blowing your usual ignorance out of the water.

I'll say it again.......Tahir and Harmer are marginally better spinners than JP and Elgar.....but you like to back losers, so no doubt you would select an average spinner at the expense of a seamer or bat and sell your side short in the process.....its your way  

Denise provide the evidence of me saying.....where in any post have I said that Nonu was poor/bog ordinary/weak or had butter fingers

Lying scum