The aftermath of the defeat to France was dripping in arrogance and soured the occasion, but it shouldn't have been unexpected. This is England after all, and being sour is what they English do best. All the excuses amid proclamations that the better team lost sounded all too familiar to me; it sounded like another Bokke excuse preceding an Erasmus tantrum. It was all the referees fault, that England played the better football. They lack something that I have been seeing among our own punditry: An ability to put the performance in context or to fathom any degree of mature analytics.
I anticipated that France would be vulnerable at the back, as I'm sure most people did, and we knew England would have their chances, but it was also expected that the French would have the clinical edge to take the game away from England, and that they did. To be perfectly honest, the French themselves missed several quality chances to pile on a heavy defeat in that second half. For me, it all comes down to how England approach the game. It's about direct speed in what amounts to a simple game. If they play a team who will commit numbers forward, there will be space for them to run into. England do not possess the ability to unlock a good defence. All this talk of this being the greatest ever England team underscores the delusion of these people. Why? Because they cannot put performance in context. It all goes back to 2018, they defeated Tunisia and then hammered Panama. After the latter, the expectations grew out of control, yet they were comfortably beaten by Belgium. They needed a penalty shootout to defeat Colombia, and then defeated an average Swedish side before losing to Croatia, who were comfortably the better team. They lost again to Belgium. This was not the mark of a great side. The EUROs saw something similar, beating teams who were not in great form, or who were simply very average on their way through a very simple draw. They were very obviously inferior to the Italians, who showed again that the English cannot play sophisticated football. Their primary weapon is speed in space, and if that doesn't yield any returns, they dive, and they dive a lot.
So, in context, this England team has been grossly overhyped. This is certainly not the best England team to ever play the game. There are similarities to the current Bok setup which wreaks, and we all know the lessons that are there to be learned will be brushed under the carpet. English football is too high on itself to see truth. But, be that as it may, they are out, and good riddance to them.
Typical English Windgats
England tournament player ratings…..apparently they were all brilliant:
Gareth Southgate
Once again proved himself to be a brilliant tournament manager. Even his critics must concede Southgate has earned the right to decide his own future. 8/10
Jordan Pickford
The man for a major tournament. Pickford made excellent saves against the United States and Senegal without making any costly errors across his five appearances in Qatar. 8/10
Kyle Walker
Recovered from injury in time to play a major part in England’s campaign. Relished his man-for-man battle with Kylian Mbappe and kept the France star relatively quiet. 7/10
John Stones
Another stellar tournament for Stones. Now started every game for England at the 2018 World Cup, European Championships and in Qatar. One of the best players of Southgate’s reign. 9/10
Harry Maguire
Southgate staked his reputation on Maguire and the Manchester United captain stepped up. Sadly, it was him who Olivier Giroud beat to the header that knocked England out. 7/10
Olivier Giroud beat Harry Maguire to the ball for France's winning goal CREDIT: Adrian Dennis/Getty ImagesLuke Shaw
England’s only out-and-out left back in Qatar. Produced a brilliant assist for the team’s first goal of the tournament and was a reliable presence for Southgate. 7/10
Jordan Henderson
Played a far bigger role than many had expected. Scored against Senegal and underlined his bromance with Bellingham in the celebration. Surely has one more tournament left in him. 8/10
Declan Rice
So important to Southgate’s team, screening the back four and helping England play out from the back. His reputation will have only increased following his performances in Qatar. 8/10
Jude Bellingham
In many ways England’s breakout star and yet it will not have surprised Southgate how well the teenager did. Scored his first international goal and looks to have the world at his feet. 8/10
Bellingham, left, scored England's first goal of the tournament against Iran CREDIT: Clive Brunskill/Getty ImagesBukayo Saka
England’s man of the tournament. Scored three goals and outshone Mbappe in the quarter-final defeat to France. What a way to respond to the heartache of the Euros. 9/10
Harry Kane
Equalled England’s goalscoring record and performed brilliantly, but, sadly, this World Cup will be remembered for Kane’s penalty miss against France that left him in tears at the final whistle. 8/10
Phil Foden
The subject of a huge clamour to get him in the team and kept his place with some scintillating moments and his first England goal for two years. 8/10
Marcus Rashford
England’s joint top scorer at the World Cup, despite only starting one game in Qatar. Might feel he should have been sent on earlier against France. 8/10
Kieran Trippier
Started England’s first two games and did absolutely nothing wrong. His set pieces were a real threat against Iran, but lost his place to Walker. 7/10
Trippier, right, put in a solid performance against the USA CREDIT: Markus Gilliar/Getty ImagesRaheem Sterling
Had his World Cup interrupted by burglars at his home in Surrey and had to leave the camp for five days. Great goal against Iran. 6/10
Mason Mount
A superb performance in the opening win against Iran. Lost his place, but won the penalty that Kane missed in the France defeat after being sent on as a sub. 7/10
Jack Grealish
Scored his first World Cup goal and got off the substitutes’ bench in every game. Like Rashford, could have gone on earlier against France. 7/10
Callum Wilson
Looked sharp as a substitute and unselfish play to set up Grealish to score against Iran. 6/10
Kalvin Phillips
A minor miracle he even made the squad, Phillips was still working his way towards full fitness when England went out. 6/10
Asked about the performance of the referee, Southgate said on ITV: "It is pointless going into that.
Not so Harry Maguire, who despite not closing down Giroud, the obvious danger on any cross, had a lot to say about the ref.
Where have we seen these kinds of ratings before? Lets look at some tournament stats:
Goals
Kylian Mbappe (France) – 5
Lionel Messi (Argentina) – 4
Marcus Rashford (England) – 3
Richarlison (Brazil) – 3
Bukayo Saka (England) – 3
Olivier Giroud (France) – 3
Cody Gakpo (Netherlands) – 3
Enner Valencia (Ecuador) – 3
Alvaro Morata (Spain) – 3
Goncalo Ramos (Portugal) – 3
Assists
Harry Kane (England) – 3
Bruno Fernandes (Portugal) – 3
Raphael Guerreiro (Portugal) – 2
Diogo Dalot (Portugal) – 2
Joao Felix (Portugal) – 2
Vinicius Jr (Brazil) – 2
Denzel Dumfries (Netherlands) – 2
Kylian Mbappe (France) – 2
Davy Klaassen (Netherlands) – 2
Jordi Alba (Spain) – 2
Theo Hernandez (France) – 2
Ivan Perisic (Croatia) – 2
Mislav Orsic (Croatia) – 2
Andrija Zivkovic (Serbia) – 2
Dusan Tadic (Serbia) – 2
Phil Foden (England) – 2
Ousmane Dembele (France) – 2
Christian Pulisic (USA) – 2
Shots (on target)
Lionel Messi (Argentina) – 22 (9)
Kylian Mbappe (France) – 21 (10)
Ivan Perisic (Croatia) – 13 (3)
Dani Olmo (Spain) – 12 (6)
Serge Gnabry (Germany) – 12 (4)
Jamal Musiala (Germany) – 12 (3)
Neymar (Brazil) – 11 (6)
Marcus Rashford (England) – 10 (6)
Memphis Depay (Netherlands) – 10 (5)
Luis Chavez (Mexico) – 10 (4)
Lautaro Martinez (Argentina) – 10 (3)
Aleksandar Mitrovic (Serbia) – 10 (3)
Robert Lewandowski (Poland) – 10 (2)
Marcos Asensio (Spain) – 10 (2)
Ismaila Sarr (Senegal) – 10 (1)
xG
Lionel Messi (Argentina) – 3.8
Robert Lewandowski (Poland) – 2.9
Kylian Mbappe (France) – 2.7
Neymar (Brazil) – 2.7
Olivier Giroud (France) – 2.4
Enner Valencia (Ecuador) – 2.3
Breel Embolo (Switzerland) – 2.3
Niklas Fullkrug (Germany) – 2.2
Key Passes
Lionel Messi (Argetina) – 16
Antoine Griezmann (France) – 14
Cody Gakpo (Netherlands) – 10
Dusan Tadic (Serbia) – 10
Ousmane Dembele (France) – 9
Mehdi Taremi (Iran) – 9
Christian Eriksen (Denmark) – 9
Theo Hernández (France) – 9
Joshua Kimmich (Germany) – 9
Christian Pulisic (USA) – 9
Passes into attacking penalty area
Lionel Messi (Argentina) – 15
Angel Di Maria (Argentina) – 11
Ousmane Dembele (France) – 10
Luka Modric (Croatia) – 10
Antoine Griezmann (France) – 9
Dusan Tadic (Serbia) – 9
Joshua Kimmich (Germany) – 9
Kevin De Bruyne (Belgium) – 9
Tackles won
Mateo Kovacic (Croatia) – 12
Jude Bellingham (England) – 11
Achraf Hakimi (Morocco) – 11
Tyler Adams (USA) – 9
Daley Blind (Netherlands) – 9
Kalidou Koulibaly (Senegal) – 9
Rodrigo Bentancur (Uruguay) – 8
Adrien Rabiot (Denmark) – 8
Sofyan Amrabat (Morocco) – 8
Noussair Mazraoui (Morocco) – 8
Interceptions
Jurrien Timber (Netherlands) – 10
Luka Modric (Croatia) – 8
Pedro Miguel (Qatar) – 8
Nathan Ake (Netherlands) – 8
Declan Rice (England) – 8
Aurelien Tchouameni (France) – 8
Josko Gvardiol (Croatia) – 7
Rodrigo Bentancur (Uruguay) – 7
Jose Gimenez (Uruguay) – 7
David Raum (Germany) – 7
Rodrigo De Paul (Argentina) – 7
Ellyes Skhiri (Tunisia) – 7
Denzel Dumfries (Netherlands) – 7
Casemiro (Brazil) – 7
Antonee Robinson (USA) – 7
Kyle Rowles (Australia) – 7
Clearances
Josko Gvardiol (Croatia) – 32
Kalidou Koulibaly (Senegal) – 30
Romain Saiss (Morocco) – 29
Dejan Lovren (Croatia) – 28
Maya Yoshida (Japan) – 24
Kamil Glik (Poland) – 23
Harry Souttar (Australia) – 22
Virgil van Dijk (Netherlands) – 21
Yassine Meriah (Tunisia) – 20
Nathan Ake (Netherlands) – 20
Successful dribbles
Jamal Musiala (Germany) – 19
Kylian Mbappe (France) – 13
Lionel Messi (Argentina) – 11
Alphonso Davies (Canada) – 11
Mohammed Kudus (Ghana) – 10
Sofiane Boufal (Morocco) – 9
Angel Di Maria (Argentina) – 9
Ismaila Sarr (Senegal) – 9
Touches in attacking penalty area
Kylian Mbappe (France) – 42
Ivan Perisic (Croatia) – 30
Jamal Musiala (Germany) – 28
Lionel Messi (Argentina) – 27
Christian Pulisic (USA) – 23
Serge Gnabry (Germany) – 21
Ismaila Sarr (Senegal) – 20
Aerial duels won
Cho Gue-sung (South Korea) – 21
Nicolas Otamendi (Argentina) – 20
Robert Lewandowski (Poland) – 16
Rodri (Spain) – 16
Ivan Perisic (Croatia) – 15
Harry Souttar (Australia) – 14
Mathew Leckie (Australia) – 14
Saves
Wojciech Szczesny (Poland) – 21
Dominiki Livakovic (Croatia) – 19
Andrees Noppert (Netherlands) – 18
Vanja Milinkovic-Savic (Serbia) – 16
Shuichi Gonda (Japan) – 15
Mohammed Al-Owais (Saudi Arabia) – 14
Mathew Ryan (Australia) – 12
Saka scores 2 against Iran and 1 against Senegal. What else? Where do England really standout in these stats? It reminds me of the Boks in the 2019 RWC; Big names that just didn't show up on the stats sheet. Vastly overrated, and we'll be hearing about the ref for years to come. It's becoming a disease in recent times.
Giroud, Mbappe, Lewindowski, Messi, Ronaldo are all sharp shooters. Kane in theory is the English equivalent, but fine a player as he is, as many goals as he scores in league play…..in the big games he just doesn’t get the crucial goals. He had a great chance early in the game but failed to lift the ball over Lloris.
So the English come across as disciplined but rather toothless.
More from Football
- FootballRound of 32: Bafana Bafana vs Canada . . .19 REPLIES · 74 VIEWS
- FootballAmazing Cabo Verde . . .7 REPLIES · 18 VIEWS
- FootballPortugal v Croatia8 REPLIES · 61 VIEWS
- FootballRound of 32 . . .21 REPLIES · 13 VIEWS
- FootballEngland down a goal at the 2nd half hydration break4 REPLIES · 46 VIEWS
- FootballSpain v Austria1 REPLIES · 38 VIEWS