Ceradunce.
Try his stats in Super 15 as well. Selective stats is what you and the other idiots specialize on. Frans made 11 tackles in two games missing one. is that enough? De Allende made 26 tackles in two tests missing 8. I agree there was too many misses - but that was because he tried to make 34 tackles in 2 matches and some where really desperate efforts.
I would really want a player who is active - than a player who is inactive, and Steyn was inactive in those tests. So lets look at Fransies last four test stats:-
FPL Steyn
1/0
11
6/20/29
60
1
7
2
1
18/5
0/0
1
0/0
So lets look at the stats of the inexperienced De Allende :
de Allende
0/0
0
3/11/31
172
6
12
1
3
30/10
0/0
0
0/0
Lets look at the stats of the two players objectively
* Frans scored a charge down try against Argentina in Mendoza -
Positive Frans* Frans converted three penalties and a try in the 4 games -
Positive Frans* Frans handled the ball 55 times - De Allende 43 times * Frans carried the ball 29 times for a meter gain of 60 meters - average gain 2,07 meters per carry - De Allende carried the ball 31 times for a fain of 172 meters - average gain of 5,55 meters per carry -
Positive De Allende * Frans made 1 line break in four matches - De Allende made 6 line breaks -
Positive De Allende* Frans beat 7 tackles - De Allende beat 12 -
Positive De Allende * Frans attempted 23 tackles - De Allende attempted 40 tackles -
Positive de Allende*
Frans made 18 tackles - De Allende made 30 tackles -
Positive De Allende * Frans missed 5 tackles for a missed tackle ratio of 21,74% - De Allende missed 10 tackles for a missed tackle ratio of 25% -
Positive Frans
Summary
Francois Steyn
Steyn did well in scoring a charged-down try and converting kicks entrusted to him. A charged-down try is a freak incident and other players are likely to covert the kicks Steyn did, but in fairness Styn must be accredited for those two issues as positives.
Steyn showed virtually nothing in attacking play - he carried the balls 29 times for a meter gain of 60 meters - ie 207 meters per carry. In effective at best
Carrying the ball 29 times - he made 1 line-break and beat 7 defenders. Ineffective in ball carries - lack physicality to do better.
Steyn attempted 23 tackles - making 18 of those. A very low tackle count for a number 12 center. Obviously did not look for work - hence the low tackle count.His missed tackle ratio is better than that of De Allende - but still ahead of the required rate of circa 14 to 15%.
In essence in all four tests Frans was a low-production player - rather ineffective in all four games.
De Allende
A very strong and effective ball-carrier averaging an average of 5,55 meters per carry - nearly double the figure of Steyn
His strength in line breaks and defenders beaten is already known - 7 line breaks beating 12 defenders in four tests is extra-ordinary.
De Allende is a very active player in defense - he is probably attempting to make some "impossible" tackles. His tackle attempts is near to double that of Steyn. His missed tackle ratio is too high and needs urgent attention.
In essence in all four tests De Allende was a high production player - effective in most aspects in all four games - his missed tackle ratio being a problem.
The above is a real indication of the effectiveness of the two players concerned. The four tests happened to be against the same teams. In the four tests
Frans played in the results were as follows:-
1 win1 draw2 losses
In the games
De Allende played in the results were -
2 wins 2 losses
It could have been the same result in the four games played - had De Allende not saved an almost certain try by Bosch in the Pretoria test last year.